What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

ディズニープリンセス How do あなた feel about how race is portrayed in ディズニー Princess films? Please explain.

46 fans picked:
They are actually very good with race in the...
They are actually very good with race in the movies.
   91%
It is offensive, tacky, and they need to stop.
It is offensive, tacky, and they need to stop.
   9%
 Jayden-G posted 1年以上前
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

22 comments

user photo
They are actually very good...
Silverrose1991 picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
I'm not sure if I understand this poll. You mean, like in PatF, Pocahontas and Mulan?
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
zanhar1 picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
I think they do just fine. They have diversity; Mulan, Pocahontas, Tiana, etc. And I don't feel like they make fun of people of color or white people. Long story short I think Disney is fine.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
hatelarxene picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
Unless you count making Tiana the only DP who spends most of her movie as an animal and not actually showing her as a human with her face...
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
Jayden-G picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
Silverrose, that and Aladdin. Sorry, most people don't focus on race when the protagonist and the area are where Caucasians are living in.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
Agree with hatelarxene.I saw a post on tumblr about disney confession and it made a good point, why's Tiana been the first African American princess appears as a frog in half of the movie?And why did they use an African people for it?
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
CRaZy_rawR picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
They handle the situation very well, imo.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
dclairmont picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
They could do better, as they're not the most accurate portrayals, but all in all they do a nice job representing diverse cultures I think.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
rosemina picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
I don't think being a frog in half of the movie has anything to do with their decision to make Tiana an African American. If it was really racistic, they wouldn't made Tiana a beautiful, intelligent and independent lady...
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
Shiki_Otherside picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
I feel the same as dclairmont :)
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
It is offens- ive, tacky, and...
shanyuisboss picked It is offensive, tacky, and they need to stop.:
I think Disney can be very racist with the way they portrayed the arabs and the chinese. People don't pay attention to how offending Mulan's Honor to us all could be offending to some chinese people. But even though Mulan was kind of offending, it wasn't that much. But it was in Aladdin. Many people on this site have told me "how is Aladdin offending?". Their are many reasons why Aladdin was a super racist movie. People think it is because of the whole Jafar thing but that isn't all. Their is alot more to it than that, and most of it is things that you wouldn't really understand unless you are arab yourself.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
Jayden-G picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
^ You know, I think you should write an article about it. I know I and many people would be interested in it from the portrayal of an Arab. Even I have to admit that out of the 4, Aladdin is the most insensitive. As an African American, if PATF was offensive to me, I would have called it out and made a post about it. At least you are being honest cause I want to hear some who oppose.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
dimitri_ picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
That's what I thought too hatelarxene. But then again, PatF can be blamed of racism for everything. Not that I disagree it isn't, but I don't think it's offensive at all. Honestly, stereotypes are okay. They are things you expect to see, just don't take it too far and Disney never has taken it too far IMO.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
rhythmicmagic picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
Well, it definitely isn't "offensive, tacky, and they need to stop." There are some mildly uncomfortable moments in some of the films, but mostly they tend to treat it the way they would any European culture- heck, a lot of times with significantly more reverence. And on Tiana being a frog half the time- that wasn't Disney's idea, though. They based PATF on "The Frog Princess" by E.D. Baker, which you can loosely see the plot of in the film. Disney's never changed the setting (basically the country of origin) of a story to make it feature a white character (though, admittedly, there are countless adaptations of Cinderella, but that was also made before the Civil Rights Movement- I wish they would remake it on one of another culture's versions, but that's unlikely to happen, and I'm digressing) and they did change the setting for PATF so Tiana could be the first African American princess. And while the culture may not always be very accurate (yes, I am looking at you, Pocahontas,) the characters are generally pretty respectfully written.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
TheFabulousFAN picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
Some of them are really offensive to someone that is that race but they only did that with some of the movies like song of the south, jungle book, and the little mermaid but that's it as far a race discrimination princess and the frog wasn't racist at all thats how it was in the 1920's I love it so...nah disney isn't bad at all with race
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
MacytheStrange picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
Aladdin is the most racially insensitive DP movie in my opinion. Mulan was a bit insensitive on some parts, but not too bad. All in all race in the DP movies are handled way better than race in some of the older Disney non-DP movies.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
Swanpride picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
As I explained here: link
Disney is actually pretty good in this regard. They could do better, but they are miles ahead of ALL the other animation studios.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
rhythmicmagic picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
Swanpride- Just out of interest, have you seen the complaints about Frozen- as far as I can tell, it's basically because the main characters are white. I'm always so tempted to bring up the fact that no one complains that we haven't had a non-white lead in a DreamWorks film since the transition to CGI, but I don't want to feed into that (mostly it's just really angry people who tend to just blindly hate white people and aren't actually rationally trying to initiate wider representation and end discrimination.)
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
Jayden-G picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
^ Oh yeah, so people expect an Asian person in scandanavia. Swanpride talked about DreamWorks lack of ethnic characters in the article too. Ignorance is such an ugly thing.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
Tygers_Eye picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
The few times they acknowledge other races exist, they portray them really well! ^^

I want to see another black princess, but after all the controversy surrounding Tiana and Naveen and PatF's lukewarm reception, the odds of that happening anytime soon are pretty slim.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
TigerRanma picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
I want my Hispanic princess!
posted 1年以上前.
last edited 1年以上前
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
rhythmicmagic picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
Jayden-G- Yeah, that article's actually where I got that little factoid :)
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
They are actually very good...
Popcornfan picked They are actually very good with race in the movies.:
"race" is a very arcaic notion.
posted 1年以上前.