Out of curiosity

maybe because not all otaku are the same. Maybe they hated this genre. Maybe they hated the 全体, 全体的です flow of the plot. whatever.

I personally liked Another as an anime. It gives off a mysterious beginning and ends with an amazeballs act. XD

I'm not sure.

Because I do 愛 that anime, and I've noted that a bunch of people in this club 愛 it too.

But when あなた check out reviews and such, they tend to be a little meh.

So I don't understand :P I found it nice and short, and completely tense and engaging with every 秒 of screentime.

I think many people did not like the dull main character (which I can agree with).