What do あなた mean between Jacob and Robert? Are あなた talking about Taylor and Robert または Jacob and Edward?
Between Jacob and Robert, I would choose Taylor because, he is もっと見る my age and he is gorgeous, fit and he seems really nice... and I've loved him for aged.
Between Jacob and Edward i'd choose Edward because I 愛 ヴァンパイア and I think Edward is nicer than Jacob (hotness wise) as far as personality goes, I like them both.