トワイライト・シリーズ

この質問に回答する

トワイライト・シリーズ 質問

Is it me または is Edward abusive and controlling

I can feel the hate already but I'm just going to come out and say it. Edward is a pushy controlling selfish person and soo OLD FASHION oh did I say OLD. Edward tried to kill himself in new moon he didn't think about his family how it would hurt Esmee and Carlisle and brother and sister he didn't think about Bella and how it would affected her (danger magnet) Controlling HOW he messed up Bella's car from keeping her see her friend telling her what to do and how to do thing I would has broke up with him the 分 that happen but Bella's stupid soo anyway. Violence he broke the tv because Bella wants to be a vampire ripped pillows on there honeymoon and everything. He doesn't give Bella any 宇宙 he's creepy as hell in twilight sneak up into her room and watch her sleep serious doesn't give her no time alone. Also having his sister kid napping her that a little extreme don't know think I know some of あなた guy well most are going to say his worry and stuff but fuck that. He's creepy abusive selfish immature for being a 100 and something vampire he's stupid ughh. I dislike him with a passion
*
Edward selfish why because he didn't think of his family when he tried to kill himself. Didn't think of how that would hurt his fosters parents または brothers and sisters forget about them. Also controlling tell her what to do and who's her フレンズ are. Telling her not to see Jacob destroying her car and everything is way overboard. バイオレット as hell breaking tv and y'all say jacob has the angry problems edward has it just as bad maybe even worst. Force her to the dance. He had jealously problem gets mad every time she brings up jacob. He acts like a baby complains all the time
loving_life123 posted １年以上前
*
I suspect this 質問 is going to wind up getting explosions of reactions. I'm sort of surprised they haven't already started. Maybe people are in shock here.
Flickerflame posted １年以上前
*
Yeah me too lml
loving_life123 posted １年以上前
*
I think he's being wayyy too overprotective so it comes off as controlling. He's never been in 愛 before---and he doesn't know what it means to be in a relationship either. He doesn't know how to be in a relationship---this is his very first one. It makes sense he has a lot to learn. Plus Bella is accident prone and involved in many accidents. She's seen too much death and heartbreak--and he wants her to be safe. I think Edward has a LOT to learn and has a lot of issues.
CynthiaMoon899 posted １年以上前
 loving_life123 posted １年以上前
next question »

トワイライト・シリーズ 回答

rkebfan4ever said:
No I don't find him abusive または controlling.He had never been in 愛 before,so he was experiencing that and overcoming his thirst for Bella's blood at the same time.He only wanted to kill himself AFTER Rosalie informed him Bella was dead,which was a misunderstanding.He was in Bella's room not to stalk her,but to listen to her sleeptalking since he couldn't read her mind.As for ripping pillows on their honeymoon,better the pillows than Bella's body,because pillows and tvs can be replaced,but a broken body can't.If any of his family had ロスト their mate,I'm sure they would have responded in the same way,by wanting to die with them,since a vampire's mate is the reason for their existence.

I know you're entitled to your opinion,but I STRONGLY DISAGREE with Edward being abusive and controlling,because I don't find him that way at all
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
*
I think the part where he watches her sleep is just over the 上, ページのトップへ creepy. I'd be creeped out for certain.
CynthiaMoon899 posted １年以上前
Flickerflame said:
1. Him being old fashioned makes sense when あなた consider that he was born and raised at the start of the 20th century.
2. He only attempted suicide AFTER he believed Bella had died, so how is that not considering her feelings? You're right in saying that he didn't think about his family then, though.
3. I agree with あなた on the Jacob related issues - telling her she can't see him, getting Alice to "kidnap" her, damaging the car etc. He's also slightly hypocritical there. How are new 狼男 too dangerous but his vampire family aren't?
4. He didn't rip the pillows (or break the bed) deliberately. It was loss of control. And better he break those than break her, right?
5. Agree with あなた about breaking in to watch her sleep while they're mere acquaintances.
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
Book-Freak said:
I think he's very controlling. Removing parts of her car and telling her who she's allowed to see is totally out of order. Also, he kept that Victoria was back for Bella which she had a right to know.
select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
*
Omg I though It was just me on here
loving_life123 posted １年以上前
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!