ハンガー・ゲーム

この質問に回答する

ハンガー・ゲーム 質問

Why do あなた think Madge was left out of the Hunger Games movie?

My friend and I absolutely 愛 the books! We both went and saw the movie when it was in cinemas, unfortunately not together, and after we both saw it, we got into a discussion about the differences between the book and the movie. The most obvious difference was that Madge didn't exist at all in the movie. This completely outraged both of us, as it changes the whole mockingjay thing!
Last night, as I was lying in bed, I asked myself "Why? Why would they not have Madge as a character?" I thought about it for a bit, then came to a conclusion; they wanted to 表示する the deep relationship between Katniss and Prim. After I came to that conclusion, I got curious. Why do あなた think Madge doesn't exist in the movie?
 Flutey_Girl96 posted １年以上前
next question »

ハンガー・ゲーム 回答

StarrDust said:
Even though Madge had a small part, I think she was a big impact in the book. She was the one who gave Katniss the Mockingjay pin afterall, which plays a huge part in both the 本 and movies. She also made Katniss think about not only her family but those who have helped her along the way (getting money to support her family) and about who else she had to keep fighting for. Even for a minor character, she was a big influence to Katniss' character.
select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
JackieA said:
maybe they couldn't find the right actress または maybe they just didn't want to add her because she plays a very minimal role. still i'm a bit sad about seeing her in the movie :(
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
*
well she gives Katniss the Mockingjay pin, so thats kinda important
darkling_menace posted １年以上前
*
I agree, that is kind of important
Flutey_Girl96 posted １年以上前
IggyIsAwesome said:
I think they took her out because 映画 have a certain length that they have to approach and if they included every single minor character then the movie would go well beyond that length. Even though she's semi-important in the novels, they changed how Katniss got her Mockingjay pin and removed any other scenes Madge would've been in.

This is why I like the 本 better. The 本 can add as many details as the 作者 wants and with no specific restrictions to how long the book can be.
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
*
I understand that there's that limit, but they could have changed something else. I guess it's one less character they have to kill off though. I prefer the 本 as well. Currently, I'm 読書 a book that's 1000 pages long, and the 次 two in the series were originally going to be one book, but the 作者 decided to スプリット, 分割 them so she could put もっと見る detail into the story
Flutey_Girl96 posted １年以上前
flabaloobalah said:
i read an 記事 about what was left out of the 映画 and reasons from the director, gary ross.

when they asked why there was no madge, he replied, "while madge is an important character because she supplies katniss with the iconic mockingjay pin, we wanted to find another way to let katniss get that pin. we decided if katniss gave it to prim to be safe, and then prim gave it to katniss to be safe, that would 表示する how touching the relationship is between katniss and prim."

i kind of agree, but i wish madge at least showed up to say goodbye to katniss. idk.
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
*
That is a good reason. Thanks for quoting the article, I wouldn't have found it otherwise :)
Flutey_Girl96 posted １年以上前
*
i dont remember if thats EXACTLY what he said. but thatss pretty close and means the same thing regardless.
flabaloobalah posted １年以上前
CnfzldUnicorn said:
So she can スイング in during catching 火災, 火 and steal the whole show. And then that's all we will remember from whole movie. I guess that they didn't want to do that in the first movie because it would be too contraversial.
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!