Although James Lafferty is freaking gorgeous OTH lost my vote because Chad Michael Murray has the body but is unfortunately cursed with a fish face imo.

^ LMAO! XD
Your comment is hilarious, even tho i like Chad's face xP

Anyways, i think OTH has better guys. James and Chad are both hot <3
On GG, i think only Chase is hot, but i sill wouldn't call him "hot". He's more of a pretty (REALLY pretty xD) face. I don't find Ed hot, but he has charm and he's sexy that's for sure. And Penn is just normal, i guess.

So yea, the Scott boys win for me. ;)
Plus, there are more hot guys in OTH, like Austin and the new guy who will play Clayton.

OTH only loses for SPN, the hottest guys are from there. ;)

one tree hill has one ... gossip girl has ... two ... haha so yeah :)

Chad = HOT
James = Super Hoooooooot!!! <3

i think both james and chad are hot, james more though ;) and on gg penn is HOT and chace is okay.

Deffo!James is pure hottnes,Chad is really hot too.Not to mantion Ausin and Bryan.
On GG I only consider Penn hot and Chace,but,yeah,he's more of a pretty one.

I love all the GG boys! They're all gorgeous!

I love James, but I can't stand squinty-eyed Chad.

OTH definitely!!
James, Chad and Austin are so hot!!
On GG, I only think Chace, and he's more of a pretyy face like cas_cat_2 and backtoblack said!! Ed has charm, but he's not hot or handsome! Penn is just regular!

OTH has James which makes it so hard for me to choose!! I don't find Chad that good looking tbh!
But GG has all the gorgeous guys! =) Penn, Chace & Ed are all freaking gorgeous!! =)

DUH? :p

OTH has only one hottie for me = James.

Chuck,Nate=GG(plus Chucks my favorite character so.....)
Nathan=OTH

chuck,Nate and dan are so freakin hot even rufus is hot.Lucas always does that face where he looks so pissed off.and nathan is cute but not as hot as chuck and nate

Nate/Chace = perfection

Lucas & Nathan Are so hot