Unfortuantely, this episode didn't hold up to my expectations. I was psyched to see Bobby again, of course; I just wish he would've had more screentime. And the sendoff they gave him (that was the third one now, by my reckoning) again felt flat and left me cold. I suppose the problem was that they crammed too much into this episode: the second trial, Bobby, Benny, Naomi, Kevin being taken by Crowley… The episode moved so fast, there was barely time for a breather, let alone real emotional moments (Dean's goodbye to Benny being the sole exception).

Also, what annoyed me was how the writers messed with the show's mythology. If I'm not mistaken, reapers can only be seen by the dead and the dying. So Sam & Dean shouldn't even have been able to interact with Ajay. And a reaper getting killed? Sorry, but I call bullshit on that. They're Death's henchmen; if there are any beings on Supernatural that are truly undying it should be them.

Good episode, but I'm more excited for the next ep with Charlie :)

Just like it,,,, i will miss Benny... hope we can see him again!

I agree with Josch about the episode's screwing up the mythology - it was rather disapointing.
BUT
The worst part was that they killed off Benny! I wanted Benny to be a recurring character (I'd be more happy if he was a main character but that was unlikely :) ). I connected with and love his character and I will be depressed thinking of the show unless they bring Benny back!