i can't decide because they both made me cry lol..:[

both... but this one more

she had such grace in that moment. made me love her even more. 5.06 was a close second. I had to sit for 5 minutes in front of the comp to make up my mind, heh.

I agree with you abs07 I would have never been able to do what she did

I got seriously choked up during this scene. I mean I think Hilarie did SUCH a great job at conveying the hurt and pain Peyton was experiencing and Chad was great at not taking over the scene. These two actors really work so well off each other.
Anyway, this scene really broke my heart.

both scenes were extremely sad! but hilarie burton is really damn good at acting sad and every time i see her cry i jst start to feel so sad and get all choked up!

niether i am not a fan of leyton

i cry everytime i watch itt!! :( i think its just peyton - i loved her in this scene- ive loved her even more this series than any other!!!
i do love 5.06 too!! hilaries also great in thiss one!
i get choked up too - im so glad im not the only one!! i thought i was such a dork hehe!

peyton was amazing in this scene i could never of let go like that

ı couldn't choose easly but ı thınk this one
besides peyton had great performances both of them

i cried in both scene, but when she let go, that hurts (my heart actually cracked)

Both!