Who was もっと見る cruel in these two scenes? アンケート Results - ワン・トゥリー・ヒル

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

ワン・トゥリー・ヒル Who was もっと見る cruel in these two scenes?

85 fans picked:

Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.

85%

Peyton in 5x09 claiming that Lindsey was a cry baby daddy's girl.

15%

mooshka posted １年以上前

Make your pick! | next poll >>

14 comments

	Leyton4ever picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: because they were supposed to be best friends and it was purposely done, i don't think peyton ever would have said what she had if she had known lindsey's father was dead. posted １年以上前.

	Dansea08 picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: Peyton had no idea about what happened to Lindsey so she just assumed that Lindsey had the "perfect" spoiled life.....and though it was rude to say this,she didn't know the truth.Brooke on the other hand knew very well about Peyton's moms and it really disgusted me to see a girl who went on and on about being betrayed be willing to hurt her ex-best friend on a much deeper level.She knew how much Peyton struggled with her adoptive mother dying and then her biological mother passing away....it was completely inconsiderate, unnecessary and truly cruel. When Peyton found out the truth about Lindsey's father she was immediately apologetic whereas Brooke not only did she never apologize for that specific comment but decided to fight with Peyton in the car right after she made that comment.I am so glad she matured because I can never imagine Adult Brooke saying something like that to anyone especially to someone she once held dear to her heart. That was definitely one of my least favorite Brooke Davis moments and one of the reasons I liked Peyton better during the High School Years then I did Brooke. posted １年以上前. last edited １年以上前

	kellyerin87 picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: NO question. There is absolutely no excuse for Brooke's behavior during this scene. And the sad part is... this isn't even the ONLY time that she made a comment like that :/ Peyton had no idea that Lindsey's dad was dead. For all she knew, she was just merely calling Lindsey a spoiled, cry baby, daddy's girl... that's it. But as soon as she DID find out about her dad's death, she apologized immediately. Unlike Brooke. Plus not to mention the fact that Peyton and Lindsey weren't even friends... as opposed to Brooke, who made her (much more hurtful) comment to her "best friend". posted １年以上前.

	carambolas picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: No contest posted １年以上前.

	leytonfaan_18 picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: Because she KNEW! posted １年以上前.

	dalma picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: Because she KNEW! posted １年以上前.

	KBCA picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: I'll always love Brooke more than Peyton, but this scene made me cringe. It's the only time (pre-season 7) I took Peyton's side over Brooke. posted １年以上前.

	alwaysforever picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: Both were being complete bitches lol and while I think Brooke had a right to be upset/catty while Peyton really didn't in season 5, this was just uncalled for. posted １年以上前.

	Dean-girlx picked Peyton in 5x09 claiming that Lindsey was a cry baby daddy's girl.: Two different people, both her supposed 'best friends', told her to stop and she didn't listen. posted １年以上前.

	TheBoySawAComet picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: ^ wow, and people call peyton/LP fans biased lmao. and so what if they "told her to stop"? they didn't tell her WHY she should stop. so she still didn't know the severity of what she was saying, like brooke did. she didn't intentionally USE lindsey's parent's death to make a jab at her, like brooke did. and she still didn't say that stuff to her BEST FRIEND, like brooke did. not to mention that they didn't even really tell her to stop. all haley said was "peyton you don't know what you're talking about"... posted １年以上前. last edited １年以上前

	energizerbunny picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: Brooke knew.Peyton didn't.Big difference Both were wrong, but Brooke was more heartless posted １年以上前. last edited １年以上前

	alex_sandra picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: to be honest, BOTH posted １年以上前.

	RoswellGirl13 picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: that was worst because they were best friends! and like Peyton said to Brooke. You knew my mom you were there with me when she died and then you made fun of her death in a joke! that is just horrible! but Peyton making fun of Lindsay and her dad, was different. because she didn't know that her dad died. so it wasn't intentional. posted １年以上前.

	svety74 picked Brooke in 4x09 making fun of Peyton's dead mothers.: It was Lindsey who started 'the rhyming war', Peyton only retaliated and answer back. However, she didn;t know about Lindsey's father so the attack was not intentional. Brooke, on the other hand, WANTED to hurt Peyton and made joke about her mother's death INTENTIONALLY to hurt her. They can't be compared IMO posted １年以上前.