Nathan b/c his shoe contract paid for it.
OR
Whoever has Jamie the most, b/c Jamie shouldn't have to move.

I agree with ElliesOwner

nate may have paid for it, but haley runs the house & takes care of the family. Nate's money would have eventually ran out (because of his injury), but hales started working as a teacher to support the family. She's provided a lot for her family as a mother and a working woman. but I agree, whoever has jamie the most should keep the house. I'm sure deciding who gets the house in that case wouldn't be a problem.

actually she doesn't that's what carrie was doing running the house. yeah but when a basketball player gets hurt before the person starts playing the team that chose him gives him a ton of money because they won't ever get to play again

carrie wasn't there for the 4 months in between when nathan was a self loathing drunk, heylow. don't forget that s5 skips alot of what happened in between.

nathan of course cause if they break up its over nothing ;)

i agree with abs07. besides, carrie was too busy trying to swoop in to be anything else. i hate her.