hes hot no matter what

i really didn't like legolas. don't get me wrong... he was still hot!

no competition!

Hard but I liked Legolas better.

Not as much of a fan of the long blond hair...

Those are the only two roles I actually like him in, along with Elizabethtown."

Well he looks better at least.

In these photos I like Will Turner better. In the movies, it's a draw.

To be honest i don't think he fit the role of legolas very well.

this is very unfair!!!!!!!!

because he's a pretty boy, haha

I love him in both roles, my biggest complaint is that people don't give him nearly enough credit as an actor, all they see is the pretty boy, but he's easilly one of the best 'straight men' in Hollywood. I've got to say though, I prefer him as Drew in Elizabethtown, I love that film.

Yummy.

Hmmmmm he's hot =) I love him in POTC ;D

But he's more then just a pretty face.

BOTH, but I felt like picking Legolas because I like that character more AND I just watched Lord of the Rings today!

As much as I think he's hot in Lord of the Rings, I think he's much more hotter as Will Turner.

Benji, I totally agree with you. I was reading through all the comments, and people are saying, 'he's hotter in this' or 'he looks better in this photo'... I think he played Legolas very well, and he was also entertaining as Will Turner. But, Legolas wins for me.

Will Turner annoys me. His role as Legolas was simple, but that's how I prefer him. Fewer lines means fewer opportunities to stink it up.

way better

Tough choice. I love Orlando, not matter what role he is playing. He has so much potential to become a good actor if anyone is willing to give him a chance. I always have chosen Legolas over Will Turner. So I chose Will.

Lord of the Rings is infinitely better Pirates of the Caribbean.

I love him as will turner