Ciel is just too sweet to die.

Hell yeah!

okay i'm only agreeing with this because he's such a huge character.... without him the show would prolly suck... like pirates of the caribbean is going to be after they take out elizabeth and will.... i actually think the series should end there, but since they're already making a second season, ciel MUST RETURNNNN :D

plus all the fan girls would be sad because Sebastianxciel!

wah~ ciel wont be playing the main role in season 2 anymore.. the same goes with sebby's role.. D':

It seems like there's a rumor going around that Sebastian didn't eat Ciel's soul after all. The hand with the contract on it got cut off from Angela, so the contract just might've been broken. But nobody really knows for sure, it's just a rumor ._.;;

Yeah, i also heard dat rumuor.But,d new anime is confirm to introduced two new characters, so ciel might not be appear, i hope the producer juz continue d anime manga where ciel is still alive!!! missing CIEL!!!!!!!!

Uh... YES! Who the heck would pick no! He's only 12 and has already been through so much. He was the one who was wronged in the past so he doesn't deserve to suffer like that! It's too sad, I wish he would have a happy ending somehow even if he did make a pact with a demon! People will make desperate decisions in desperate situations. After all, he's only human BTW! Sebastian is still my favorite character. I just hate the idea of Ciel suffering in Hell. That's depressing! It makes me want to cry and give him a big hug.

I've already watch Kuroshitsuji season 2 and Ciel is not died.So happy!!!

Ciel cant die i wont let him!

If Ciel died then that (stuped) Alois would be the only one who would show up in the series and then Sabastian wouldn't be in it. Sides They wouldn't call it Kuroshitsuji season2 if Sabastian wern;t in there,]. I hate the new main chericter. Alois is dumb! >.>

Who'd picked "Sebastian should eat his soul"??

well he's the main character here!

Of course he should live c:
Even though it left Sebastian sort of unhappy n__n;

No, he should live!! And Sebastian should be his butler!

but i don`t get it,why did claude want to have his soul in stead of his own master`s? maybe it`s cause his such a pervert!!!

I'm just about to watch the second season this afternoon so IDK what happened in the 2nd season but I heard he's still on it. 8D

It wouldn't be Black Butler without him

They should alter their pact to say:

"I Ciel Phantomhive grant to Sebastian Michealis the VERY EXISTANCE OF MY BEING. *Rather then soul* And promise to love him in sickness and in health as lon as we both shall live.


Then seal it with a kiss, CHU ;D

If sabast.. Ate ciels soul then there might not even be any more kuroshitsuji icant wait until the 3 season though!!!!!!!!

If Ciel died, Alois wouldn't excist! T.T

I CANT DECIDE. i want ciel to live, but at the same time not as a demon...but if they did make sebas eat his soul in season 2, i would probably cry but at least i know that he wont turn into a demon and make sebas his slave forever then i would prefer the sebas ate his soul ending. XD

I think it would have been nice,if he did..but sometimes I find it hard to believe in a way that Sebas-chan would eat Ciel's soul,and if Ciel passed in season 2 there wouldn't be an Alois!..and there might not even be a Kuroshitsuji if Ciel went..well becoming a demon,that's something different,but if he passed,no thank you.

without Ciel NO kuroshitsuji

agreed @Pk2956 if Ciel die Kuroshitsuji will be so boring

@XxAMIxX and Pk2956:Agreed ^^

****SPOILER IF YOU HAVENT FINISHED SEASON TWO BROS *********

My only reason for choosing this is because i really hate the fact that Ciel turns into a demon >:/ an teases Sebby that now he will never get the soul. So Go get it Sebby ><

Who in the world would choose eat his soul? If u like the show u want ciel to live. (unless u wach it to make fun of it) but then they would be a hater. And why would a hater be in this club in the first place!

Personally, I prefer Ciel in a demon form, though I was sad for all of the other characters when he left, ecspecially the servants :(

I don't like Ciel but I just don't like when a character dies. ;n;

I agree with you OtakuLove but I wish Ciel wasnt a demon and I hope hes not a demon in Kuroshitsuji:Book of Circus

OF COURSE!!!! Just think ladies... if Ciel dies, Sebastian won't have a reason to still be with him!!!! AND I WANNA SEE MY BAE, SEASBTIAN!!!!!!!!

I feel he should live (he is my favorite anime character) but I think the story would be more interesting if it ends off with Sebastian eating his soul because that's what was promised :(