この質問に回答する

Inception (2010) 質問

What happens when あなた kill yourself in limbo?

Here is my understanding on the concept of limbo in Inception. If あなた are heavily sedated and あなた happen to die within the dream, your mind goes into a state of limbo または あなた travel to limbo, whichever one. My 質問 is, what happens if あなた kill yourself in limbo?


 Sp1r1t posted 1年以上前
next question »

Inception (2010) 回答

VintageSmile said:
Well if あなた kill yourself and the timer in the dream machine hasn't expired, あなた still end up back in limbo, unaware of the fact that you're still in there または the awareness that it's a dream becomes vague. If the timer on the machine reaches zero and you've forgotten where あなた really are, あなた accept it as reality (become older like Saito and die).

Hope that helps, I got confused too.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Not necessarily. I don't want to be an 尻, お尻 but in the movie, Aurthur explains that if あなた die in a dream when the timer has not expired, あなた wake up. But if あなた are heavily sedated and あなた kill yourself, あなた can't wake up and end up in limbo. If Cobb was in limbo for 50 years, why didn't he kill himself when he first got there? What would happen?
Sp1r1t posted 1年以上前
*
Lol, not at all. I just got all that off インターネット・ムービー・データベース(IMDb) :P
VintageSmile posted 1年以上前
*
That is what I ponder.
Sp1r1t posted 1年以上前
MisterKnite said:
It's the only way out.

Originally Mal and Dominick stay in limbo for 50 years because Dom couldn't get Mal to believe that limbo wasn't reality until he planted the seed of the idea in her mind (Inception). He didn't do this until they lived through 50 years in limbo and he was utterly convinced, finally becoming desperate to get back to his children.

It is unclear what kind of sedation process Dom and Mal went through, but I believe that despite what happens to your physical body あなた must kill yourself in limbo または あなた stay there for what seems to your mind as eternity, slowly going insane. This is why they all wake up on the plane at the same time regardless of all the diversions the plan took, as they all physically wake at the same time no matter what, but their minds perceived different spans of time from hours または days to fifty years.

The tragedy of the movie is in saving his wife and himself from the madness of infinity, Dom plants the seed of an idea that consumes Mal in life, and out of 愛 for him she tries to save him from the same fate によって forcing him to kill himself.

Truly rife with irony.


select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Unfortunately I can't say how long exactly they must wait out the sedation, I just think that the time they experience in limbo is an illusion, of sorts. Does this help at all Spirit?
MisterKnite posted 1年以上前
Witchcatjuh said:
Well, Mal and he liked it in Limbo. They were like Gods there and they could create an entire world. That was what they wanted. Then, Dom realized that they had to get back to what was real. To their children. So, he decided to commit suicide. At first, he didn't really think about it, because he was quite happy in Limbo. When he and Mal commited suicide, they ended up back where they were when they fell asleep. At least, this is believing the movie was not an entire dream and Dom is still in Limbo.

So, either あなた stay in Limbo, because あなた are confused about what is real and not (Look at Mal, she thought she was still in Limbo and the world wasn't real, but Saito thought Limbo was real) または あなた wake up again. Both is possible, I believe.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
So why stay there for 50 years? Why not kill yourself to get out as quickly as あなた can?
Sp1r1t posted 1年以上前
*
Saito didn't realize he was in Limbo. Limbo became his reality. Dom & Mal didn't really realize where they were, but Dom knew it wasn't the real world. At first they liked it, then he wanted to leave. Mal wanted to stay, so they did. In the end, he couldn't take it anymore, so they left. That's why they stayed for 50 years. Saito just took Limbo as his reality.
Witchcatjuh posted 1年以上前
maddy5497 said:
when あなた kill yourself in limbo あなた go back to the real world. remember how cobbs wife and himself had to do that to escape limbo the first time
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
But why did they stay there for 50 years?
Sp1r1t posted 1年以上前
*
because limbo limbo became their reality
vv2bel posted 1年以上前
Eternal-fighter said:
あなた wake up in the real world if the sedative wore off.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
digitalis said:
Well, obviously if あなた kill yourself whilst in limbo あなた wake up, または at least wake to the level of dream before limbo. または at least that seems to be what was implied in the movie, considering when Dom and Mal were in limbo for all those years, Dom performed inception on Mal, making her believe that in order to wake up they had to kill themselves, which is what they did, on the train tracks. So, when the train hit them, they woke up to where they were lying on their living room floor. And whenever Dom and Ariadne entered limbo to retrieve Fischer and Saito, Ariadne got Fischer - and herself - out of limbo and to the preceeding level of the dream によって falling off the building, effectively killing themselves. I am assuming Dom did something to that effect with himself and Saito to get them out as well. So, my point is, the movie implies - but does not state directly - that the way to exit limbo is によって committing suicide.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
MomoThePuppy said:
According to the movie, Cobb and Saito killed themselves to wake up. So apparently あなた wake up.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
vv2bel said:
well if you're heavily sedated then i think あなた stay in limbo but otherwise あなた wake up, in the movie Cobb had to convince Mal to kill herself によって planting that idea in her. that was in limbo and once they got run over によって the train they woke up from limbo.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
next question »