Is that even a question? POA was the WORST movie EVER! I really hated it! I don't like the movies in general, but HBP was good in comparation to the others [I liked him the most, maybe because it had a lot of Bellatrix and Snape scenes:P and a lot of Draco also<3 even more than there should have been, but I'm not complaining.] and POA was... argh, the only reason I would see this movie is to laugh at it. Or cry because they ruined my favorite book. X_X

Half Blood Prince is the best movie they made<3
POA was a bit boring..

both are ok, but i prefer HBP hellva lot more LOL

Much better. Harry Potter and Prisoner of Azkaban is my Least favorite film out of they 6 movies some are.

POA was AMAZING! <3
I don't get why is loosing.
HBP was awesome too, but in certain parts they made it look a bit like a joke.

Well wanna know what I think? I think that Half Blood Prince is the most OVERRATED Harry Potter movie ever made. Each and every Harry Potter movie that I first saw at the cinema/theatre I loved. But when I first saw Half Blood Prince, I actually was so close to walking out of the cinema because it was sooo boring! The only reason why I stayed was because I kept thinking "Oh if Ill go Ill miss a good bit" - but did I miss any good bits? No. I have read the books several times and Im a big fan but i dont see everyones obssession with the 6th movie? I actually think the 6th is one of the worst movies out of all of them! HBP was so jumbled and all they focused on was romance! HBP is the most vital book out of the first 6 and they didnt include any important information.. dunno how the heck theyre making Deathly Hallows after what they did to HBP.. theyll probably try to forget the things that went wrong in HBP because so many things were wrong.

Whereas Prisoner of Azkaban is my favourite. I know people have different opinions but i actually cant believe that someone above said that "PoA is boring" - maybe they were watching a different movie when they saw Half Blood Prince.

Sorry, rant over.

I agree with Mongoose, HBP was the worst one for me out of the whole series.

OMG I love both so much!!! why are people so critical of these two movies? I've noticed that. So far, I love all of the movies!! :D

By FAR! HBP was the worst one IMO.
The Prisoner of Azkaban was the best!

one of my all time fav's

HBP was the worst HP movie, POA was WAY better.

i totally agree with mongoose!

HBP was the second worst HP movie (OOTP being first). POA is one of my favourites!!

By far. HBP was the WORST HP movie in my opinion. I actually liked OOTP okay, but the HBP...

I liked HBP, but PoA was one of the best. I don't know why, but in some parts of HBP, it really annoyed me, although, the fight scene in the toilets between Harry + Draco was awesome, but PoA introduced all these characters, and in my opinion, had amazing effects and everything. Just talking about it, make me want to watch it. :D

My biggest problem with PoA was that it was the first movie in the series to start messing with the plot. Quite a few plot holes were created starting with this movie, and from there on, the films have been deviating much too far from the original source material. They almost feel like separate franchises, the books and movies (starting with the third) So, I guess my biggest problem is that PoA began the slippery slope.

HBP was complete rubbish.

Ok, not complete rubbish. Snape was good, Draco was (surprisingly) good, Tom Riddle was amazing. The rest of the film felt like a weird Harry Potter spoof movie. They tried to focus too much on the relationship/comedy aspect, which in my opinion should have been a minor plot point. And I understand changing aspects of the story to make it easier to transfer to film, but I always thought HBP would be the easiest to translate, and somehow they completely screwed it up. Why add scenes that aren't canon when you could use that time to incorporate scenes that are essential to plot and development? The train station scene in the beginning was a joke. The Burrow fire scene was unnecessary and just didn't make any sense. A lot of the acting and characterizations were just ridiculous.

its my favorite of the harry potter movies

Prisoner of Askaban 'coz Harry starts a "relationship" (not in love but u see what I meant) and see the last (if we don't include his uncle and aunt) family member that he has : Sirius.