この質問に回答する

ハリーポッター 質問

The final fight- which version?

Which version of the final fight between Harry and Voldemort do あなた profer? Personally, I find the one in the book to be miles above the movie, I loved how Harry revealed to everyone that Snape was actually after a good man after all, amongst other facts. Don't get me wrong, im not condoning the movie, it was visually brilliant, however, it felt like it didn't really tie up the loose ends. I just thought I'd see what others thought about this :)
*
I agree.I loved that final ディベート between them. I also didn't like in the movie that nobody actually saw Voldemort's defeat and Harry's great victory.
rosemina posted 1年以上前
 LG194 posted 1年以上前
next question »

ハリーポッター 回答

dragonsmemory said:
Actually, both versions are equal in my eyes. In the book version, I adore Voldemort's denial of the truth even when it stared him in the face. The movie version of Voldemort's destruction was certainly better than the book's. There are other, もっと見る minor, details that I could discuss, but it is 安全, 安全です to say that both versions do the event justice. (In a fanfic I'm working on, I'll be combining the best bits of both versions.)
Of course, having been a Potterhead nearly all my life, I can safely say that the 映画 were not meant to be watched without a good graasp of the books.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
alexisn10 said:
Movie for me (which never happens lol). It was so well made and touching. The movie in the background did it for me :)
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
zar_far11 said:
I 愛 the movies, but I have to say the book version was better. I was glad that Harry trash-talked Voldy and got some facts across, like Voldemort would never know 愛 または friendship. In the movie, Voldemort just crumpled up like paper. Though with visual effects, it looked cool, but honestly, is that how we wanted this epic journey to end? The bad guy just crumples into waste? Dont get me wrong I 愛 the 本 & 映画 @ the same level but i have to admit the book version of the final duel was もっと見る thrilling.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
next question »