I think あなた really have to see it on your own, in order to form an opinion on it. I personally didn't care for it, but あなた may 愛 it. Dalton is decent as Rhett, but I thought that Whalley's 芝居 fell flat. She couldn't pull off a southern accent either, which is kind of a big deal since Scarlett is a southern belle. The ending was great, but other than that, I didn't really care for it. Many times, the 芝居 seemed overdone to me, like a soap opera. However, I know some people who actually like "Scarlett" better than "Gone With the Wind" so maybe あなた should still give it a chance. =)