That Glee'd icon says it all.

u could just feel that something while they where singing i want rachel to break up with jesse before she realizes he is playing her like a second hand piano, and get together with finn

their were amazing as always :)

ADORE THIS!!!!

I loved it!!! Oh I just loved it! It was my second fave right after like a virgin

No contest.

Rachel did okay, but her and Finn couldn't hold a candle to Madonna. I think the song would have been so much better if Puck was singing, or even Artie.

Open your Heart is my absolute favorite Madonna song of all time. I was really glad they did it, and the mash-up was cool and all, but I would have loved a pure Open your Heart cover more.

BY FAR.