A lot of people on the ファン spot for the 表示する BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- are trying to claim that 城 is a cheap trashy remake of Bones, this is one of the least true things I've ever heard, what are your opinions?

I think it's stupid when people try to claim that and it really annoys me, I don't even see where they could get that idea.
 Jeffersonian posted 1年以上前
next question »

回答

Mirrie said:
I agree. I'm a BIG BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- fan...from the beginning and 城 too, but 城 is really different from Bones. It's way もっと見る comedy, their relationship is just different, etc, etc.
The only thing in common is that both the "cops" work with someone who's not a cop and that there's sexual tension. I really don't see that much similarities....
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Just adding similarities: 城 writes crime novel so does Brennan,Beckets mother was murdered so was Brennens,Beckets dad is still alive so is Brennans,there was an episode based on the murders in their books,strong willed mostly seriouse female carachters ,brave and witty male charachters that are willing to risk their life for their female partners, and there are so many もっと見る but I decided not to bore anyone
BonesAddict622 posted 1年以上前
Cinders said:
I am a big BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- ファン and a big 城 fan... but I kind of like 城 just a little better, partly because it's new and exciting and there's still a lot to learn about the characters.

There ARE several things in common between BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- and Castle, but for me, that just makes it もっと見る interesting. For example, both BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- and 城 星, つ星 former Whedon stars (Boreanaz and Fillion, respectively). Both BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- and 城 involve writers (Brennan, Castle) and both BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- and 城 involve solving crimes. They both have a strong-willed, serious (but not always) female lead, and a witty, somewhat goofy (but not always) male lead. There is sexual tension between the leads on both shows.

But if we were to take this to mean that 城 was a knockoff of Bones, then we'd also have to say that NCIS 〜ネイビー犯罪捜査班 is a knockoff of JAG and/or CSI. We'd have to say that CSI:科学捜査班 is a knockoff of Forensic Files.

It's kind of like that crazy コメント I read によって a girl who claimed that "Wolfman" was a knockoff of "New Moon" just because they both involved werewolves. Is the premise of 城 an old premise? Yes - but it's a premise that works. Which is why shows like BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- and Castle, as well as Law and Order and CSI, and even House, which all use that mix of crime, mystery, quirkiness and sexual tension to draw あなた in, are as successful as they are.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
NCIS 〜ネイビー犯罪捜査班 is actually JAG's sequal, but I still don't really find that just because 城 and BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- have writers and strong willed females means 城 is Bones' ripoff
Jeffersonian posted 1年以上前
*
No, 城 isn't Bones' ripoff. If it were, then we'd have to say that BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- was a ripoff of other male/female detective teams, including Moonlighting and Lawa and Order. These shows have similar formulas, but each one shakes it up and presents it in its own way. On a side note - I just looked it up and you're right - NCIS 〜ネイビー犯罪捜査班 is a spin-off of JAG. I'm an idiot. Ah, well, my point still stands.
Cinders posted 1年以上前
Persephone713 said:
I have watched one episode of BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- and almost all the episodes of Castle. I 愛 城 because it seems to have もっと見る of a balance between the light and dark moments. And I like the humor in Castle. AND not to mention I keep wanting Beckett and 城 to キッス AlREADY!
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
tabbyhearts said:
I see where people get it, and that's what some of my フレンズ have told me too. Yet shows have to start somewhere, and in my opinion, two shows can be almost alike without being the same. Yeah, I see where BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- and 城 are alike, but no, it's not really a cheap remake.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
Xoxjessica said:
I have watched only one episode of BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- and it's so different!
I was totally into 城 the moment I watched my first episode because it has a combination of drama, humour, and crime :) But BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- is もっと見る serious and it doesn't have the humour factor~!
They are two totally different shows...
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
Ash24 said:
I 愛 BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- and castle, 城 is much different to BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- though they have the same chemistry as BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- and booth, its completely different story and もっと見る interviewing the suspects then seeing what happened to them, but it like any 表示する really they r similar in some way
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
BonesAddict622 said:
城 is really awesome,its a remake, but definitely not trashy または cheap.I 愛 城 and BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- but I loved BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- first so BONES(ボーンズ)-骨は語る- is my お気に入り 表示する , but 城 has made it to my 上, ページのトップへ three .Don't know if it is 秒 または third, they are both amazing in there own way.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
next question »