この質問に回答する

ビッグバン★セオリー/ギークなボクらの恋愛法則 質問

What event または incident do あなた think would bring the emotionally barren Sheldon to his knees?

As we know, Sheldon is basically clueless about human feelings and emotions and rarely expresses any true emotion himself. So is there anything that could happen which would totally break down Sheldon's defences and devastate him?

My vote would be for the death of his Meemaw. He has actually 発言しました in an episode that he would be "an inconsolable puddle of Moonpie" if she died. However, do ファン have any other ideas about what could achieve the impossible and devastate Sheldon?
 BeastsGirl posted 1年以上前
next question »

ビッグバン★セオリー/ギークなボクらの恋愛法則  ベストアンサー

amshafe said:
I personally think that one of the big reasons Sheldon is this way is because of his childhood. Of course he is Sheldon, he's very eccentric and him being closed off emotionally is also partially due to his personality.

But he has talked about how his dad was an alcoholic and left his mom for a bartender, and how he tried to change him into the son he really wanted. His mom was obviously devestated from the whole situation and turned to religion because of it. I think Sheldon, as a kid, probably closed himself off to emotions and intimacy because of this, to protect himself. Notice how he freaks out when people start yelling at each other and fighting.

I think Sheldon is interesting because so many people say he's asexual, but he's actually not. Humans can't be asexual. He's celibate, which is a choice and not something that is just a part of you, and again I think this just is a symptom of his unwillingness to break down the ウォール to his emotions.

Childhood trauma can really affect people and I think that's the root of a lot of his issues. Sheldon is human, he's not a robot, and noone can convince me that he could go through what he did as a kid and not be affected.

I think that him losing any of his close friendships, which have actually helped him evolve so much as a character, would be devestating to him, because of his past and the way I think he really counts on his friendships and relationships without even knowing it. Sheldon is evolving, he's not the same person he was in Season 1. And that's because of his relationships with these characters. They've all changed and had an effect on each other. I think Leonard, Penny, and Amy have been most influential on Sheldon. I think anything happening to those three relationships would be very devestating, whether it's b/c something happens to one of them または Sheldon is cut off from them somehow.

I see those three as like the three tiers of relationships that Sheldon has come to rely on. Leonard kind of introduced him to the world of real friendship. And Penny really expanded his world. She was unlike anyone he usually was surrounded by, it was like a new perspective. And Amy is his first romantic relationship, and she gives Sheldon アドバイス and kind of balances some of Sheldon's もっと見る extreme qualities. Leonard, Penny, and Amy are always the people he turns to for advice. He's definitely the closest with those three. So they are the key to breaking down Sheldon's defences IMO.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
× I really like your analysis here. I definitely agree that Sheldon's childhood left it's mark which is evidenced, as あなた said, によって his reactions to people who are arguing/fighting. I also feel that Sheldon may have been left with a strong sense of isolation due to his childhood. After all, his parents and his siblings were 'normal' whereas he was this prodigy who they couldn't relate to and so just left him to his own devices. This is why I think Meemaw is so important to him; she treated him like a normal kid while also appreciating his intelligence. Anyway, I won't say anymore as this is Sheldon we're talking about so we could be here for months :-) Thanks for your reply.
BeastsGirl posted 1年以上前
*
^Yep, exactly. And I agree, Meemaw didn't make him feel alone like everyonee else did. I think anything happening to his Meemaw would also do the trick. Really any of his important relationships.
amshafe posted 1年以上前
next question »

回答

joe-kerr said:
Death of his meemaw, または his mother, または any of his フレンズ would do it. He's human, after all.

A less extreme possibility is if he's in a situation where Leonard, Raj and Howard aren't there for him. For a long stretch of time. I think he'll finally realize how much he needs them. (There have been some precedents, but none of them was permanent.)
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
Chaann94 said:
^Agreed. But there's also one much もっと見る simple and easier example.

Do we all remember how Sheldon was when he couldn't finish his sentence?

Or....

When it hits Sheldon that he's not the smartest person alive. XD
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Yes, Chaann94!! Totally forgot about when the genius kid eclipsed him. I'd never actually felt that sorry for Sheldon before that.
BeastsGirl posted 1年以上前
shenelopefan said:
That is true

"No one calls me Moonpie but Meemaw"
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
simpleplan said:
A lot of things could. ロスト of a 愛 one, an accident, his フレンズ leave him, Amy breaking up with him, his ホーム being gone, his childhood bully comes back and so on.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
Bubba38 said:
i think he wood lose it if either meemaw または leonard nemoy died...his meemaw bc well its his meemaw and shes ta only one tht can kall him moonpie :) but he wood lose it w/leonard nemoy bc he wood realize tht he has ta napkin 2 make a clone...
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
smbatt said:
I think meeting leonard nemoy
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
detty4ever said:
Sheldon could be brought to his knees if he'd realize that he can no longer supress his desires and he starts falling in 愛 with a woman, a.k.a Penny.
Maybe a キッス would help. Sheldon Cooper would have to deal with the fact that he's not Vulcan and that he too, can experience feelings of true love. So instead of death, I'll go with love.
select as best answer
 Sheldon could be brought to his knees if he'd realize that he can no longer supress his desires and he starts falling in 愛 with a woman, a.k.a Penny. Maybe a キッス would help. Sheldon Cooper would have to deal with the fact that he's not Vulcan and that he too, can experience feelings of true love. So instead of death, I'll go with love.
posted 1年以上前 
*
1. SHAMY FOREVER 2. Shenny will never happen (Yay!)
mermel305 posted 1年以上前
*
Never say never.
detty4ever posted 1年以上前
*
Shenny FTW!
HousesCane posted 1年以上前
marvel-glimmer said:
I think Sheldon would crack if he was fired from the University, his Meemaw died または if Leslie Winkle won the Nobel Prize. :)
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
i agree with ta leslie winkle thing haha
Bubba38 posted 1年以上前
mellissastinson said:
I totally think the death of his Meemaw would do it または another family members または friends.
Also maybe if someone did something he really didn't like such as destroying all of his collectables, like when penny and him are at war basically and they are both sabotaging each other if penny had gone in and opened all the figures he has in the boxes または drawn in his mint condition comics like she 発言しました she would, または destroying all of his research, like when they all comeback from the north pole and Howard and raj reveal that they tampered with his work he was pretty bumed out so maybe if it turned out all of the work he had been doing his whole life was tampered with that may do it.
Just a few ideas :)
Oh and maybe if something were to happen between him and Amy? I don't know that one was a last 分 thought :)
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
mermel305 said:
If someone ストール, 盗んだ all his comic 本 definitely
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
avrillavigne82 said:
I think it will be when one of his フレンズ becomes もっと見る of a smart-alic than he is! I'd 愛 to see that! =)
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
alliXcobber said:
death of MeemMaw for sure
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
DTKs_Girl said:
Either seeing Amy with a guy smarter than him, または his " Meemaw " dying.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
randomgirl3000 said:
Stan lee dying
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
BubeeM said:
Um... several,
When that genius kid was smarter then him, uh... When they were robbed... Um... Darn I hate it when Im about to say something then I forget what to say.....
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
FeelicityW said:
If he met Marilyn バン Savant
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
davidmason25 said:
If his memaw died
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
next question »