Lucas and Nathan piss me off, and don't provide enough eye-candy. Especially Nathan.

LOVE LOVE LOVE!

Lucas and Nathan are nothing compared to Dean&Sam!

I don't like Lucas at all.

<3 =P

I like Nate and Lucas too, but like SG1 said they are nothing compared to Dean and Sam!

I've only watched a little bit of One Tree Hill- it's just not my cup of tea, er coffee. But c'mon, the Winchester brothers are the best brothers ever! What siblings could compare to them, really? ;D

I like Dean and Sam

dean for me is the best eye-candy on tv, and i love sam so naturally the winchesters win again

For those that don't watch OTH i like Lucas and Nate too BUT Lucas is a spoilt brat who needs everything his own way otherwise he throws a strop and he is quite judgemental and hypocritical at the same time. Nathan is better but still he's abit more of a push over always bending to other people's will even when he's right (his wife Haley for example) plus Nate often wallows in self pity - like when he lost his basket ball dream and couldn't walk he became all drunk and angry. So yeh - like i said....NOTHING on the Winchesters ;)

^^^^totally well said!!!!! i love my scott brothers but compared to my winchester bros COME ON ITS NO COMPARISON

=D

i like the oth brothers because the are like the best basket ball players in the world but they are nothing comrared tor sam and dean winchester because they might be able ton play basket ball but sam and dean hunt they hunt demands i am on the part that they are hunting my favorate demand and that is the yellow eyed DEMAND

i like nathan better then sam , but i like dean like 47654594654 times better then all of them : )

Oh, is that where this Lucas and Nathan that I keep hearing about are from?

I've only seen a couple of eps of One Tree Hill but I like Sam and Dean best

SAM AND DEAN... bbutttt I've never seen One Tree Hill

there is no competition whats so ever when it comes to choosing!!!!

I've never watched One Tree Hill. As Castiel said "I don't understand that reference" lol.....

lol i don't understand that reference
(either)

i agree with kelsey887 i love dean billion times more then all of them and i agree with fifthbitten

I love them both