Critical Analysis of Twilight

この質問に回答する

Critical Analysis of Twilight 質問

Didn't Bella rape Edward ? Instead of him raping here ? ( もっと見る reasons in the description)

Okay the reason asked was because here the rules are ( not sure about America):
If an adult ( 18 または over) decides to have intercourse with someone not an adult yet.
Its called sexual assualt ! It doesn't matter if your married having a sexual relationship is also rape.
So likely Edward is 17 and Bella is 18 and well they had sex so ...
Any ideas ?
:)

 Renesmee_XD posted １年以上前
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight 回答

bri-marie said:
In America, where Twilight was written, if an adult (18 または over) has sex with someone under the age of consent (that varies place to place, but generally the age of consent is 15) it's considered rape. If the person is the age of consent または over, it's not. So, in that logic, Bella didn't rape Edward.

Also, Edwards been "17" for over a hundred years, so I'm pretty sure he's 安全, 安全です from Bella's advances either way.
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
*
Okay so it's 15 there that's fine thanks :) and lol at the last point ;)
Renesmee_XD posted １年以上前
*
;)
bri-marie posted １年以上前
*
Huh, that's strange, I was told it was 16. So I don't have to wait 11 days after all! =)
sapherequeen posted １年以上前
*
Well, it depends on where あなた live. [i]Generally [/i] it's 15 または 16. Here's a link: link
bri-marie posted １年以上前
sapherequeen said:
No, not really. Yes, Edward is a minor. But he's above the age of consent, and Bella is only a 年 older than he is. So I wouldn't call it statutory rape at all.

What would make it scandulous is if Bella was 21-years-old または older.
select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
*
Really, really good answer.
Karipoof posted １年以上前
HecateA said:
he "ages" in the series too, he's supposedly 18, he is just アナと雪の女王 with the looks of a 17 年 old.
Plus あなた have to be 18 to get married without parental permission (which he has anyways, but still)
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
*
But Stephenie Meyer particulary 発言しました he stayed "17"...
Renesmee_XD posted １年以上前
*
But humans would ask 質問 if he always stayed the same age, so the cullens say he turns 18 または whatever even if his body is アナと雪の女王 as a 17 year-old
HecateA posted １年以上前
Hiding 3 comments... click to show.
*
yes well, nobody but Bella, the cullens and whatever his name is know its fraud, so to authoroties it counts and thye see Edward's aged even if he hasn't
HecateA posted １年以上前
Matsy23 said:
O_o
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
VictoriNoRisuu said:
In Poland Bella is 安全, 安全です - legally, two people can have sex when they are 16, if they both want of course ;)
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
zanesaaomgfan said:
What? Bella is 18 and Edward was 111. So no not really.
select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
qtpievy said:
if your parent says its ok then the police dont bother you. charlie had a sex talk with her he didnt say she couldnt have it so......no nobodys raping anybody!!
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!