There's a theory floating around that Claire is already dead, she died when her house was rocketed. As of now, she is a ghost または apparition, similar to Christian Shepard または Charlie.

For the theory

- Claire wasn't hurt, even though the entire house was destroyed.
- Claire thought Sawyer was Charlie when he first found her. It is possible that she actually was talking to Charlie, before she came to.
- This is why she leaves with Christain, another apparition, and leaves Aaron.
- After Sawyer rescues Claire, he asks if she is all right. She 返信 with somethign along the lines of "at least I'm not...