What do あなた think would happen if Rusty/Firestar never came into the Clan?

half the clan ネコ would be gone, and eventually all of the clans would be nothing but a memory

no power of 3. no going 2 the lake. scourge would b alive still. they would hav all died によって Omen of the Stars

Thunderclan would be distroyed

TierStar wold have sucseded and everyone would be dead

I am sure ThunderClan would be fine. At least no kittypets would be infesting ThunderClan. Firestar is responsible for all of that.

DEATH!!!!!!! MWAHAHAHAHAHA

ravenpaw would be dead bluestar, graystripe, and any other Thunderclan ネコ that hated him would be dead faster. Darkstripe would be deputy, they all would have been killed によって twolegs, Yellowfang would have dies sooner, Brokenstar would still be alive. Maybe scorge would be ruler. They would still be hunted によって dogs. Feathertail and Stormfur would have died bye his name. and sooooooo much more

i think that tigerstar would have killed bluestar an ravenpaw taken over all the clans then they would all be totaly distroyd

They will all die because Firestar was the one to answer the prophecy

Ravenpaw would probably be killed, Greystripe would probably stay with RiverClan because he doesn't have a best friend in ThunderClan and Sandstorm would have ended up with Dustpelt.

Tigerstar would've made all the Clans TigerClan!!!

This is a fluff question. If あなた wanted to ask a harder one, あなた should have asked what would have happened if Snowfur hadn't mated with Thistleclaw, または if Gray Wing hadn't gone after Jagged Peak.

Even better question:
What if Firestar woke up as a あなた kittypet in his twig nest after Omen of The Stars?

I would have instead. によって the way, I 愛 firestar