この質問に回答する

トワイライト・シリーズ 質問

Did あなた notice the flaw in Eclipse about how Bella thinks of her life?

In the middle of Eclipse, Bella is listening to Rosalie talk about her perfect human life. She also made a コメント to Bella about how miserable Bella's life on Earth was; and Bella came back right away and 発言しました that her life wasn't miserable. In fact, her life wasn't miserable at all!

And then at the end of Eclipse, Bella gives Edward a long speech about becoming a vampire, because all her life (18 years! hah!) she's always felt out of place, out of step, and fumbling thru life. And she knew that によって becoming a Vampire that she would actually fit in, and feel good about herself.

I find that this flaw gives あなた the impression that perhaps Bella is too young to make such a huge decision in changing her life. Especially when she says that her human life wasn't miserable at all. For me, it is too bad that they couldn't find some sort of cure to make Edward human again!! Now THAT would be Cool!!!!

 Did あなた notice the flaw in Eclipse about how Bella thinks of her life?
*
I had written a storyline for a show, many years ago, about how a vampire could become human. If あなた want me to post the Story in the 記事 Section, just let me know. I will also post this as an Answer so I can get もっと見る feedback if people want to read it または not. I guess we'll see! Thank あなた BOTH for commenting on this Answer. I wasn't aware that this wasn't in the 本 because I want to see the 映画 First THEN read the books. ;D
JulietAtHeart posted 1年以上前
*
SEE!! all of my フレンズ say i should read the 本 THEN see the 映画 but i wanted to do it the other way around and finally someone else who gets it! :))
rosalie2714 posted 1年以上前
 JulietAtHeart posted 1年以上前
next question »

トワイライト・シリーズ 回答

elstef said:
I dont really think it's a flaw, because feeling out of step does not necassarily mean that she was miserable. I think also that they are two different things, because she probably feels that, while her human life is a good one, it isnt the right one for her.
Also, that speech at the end of the movie was a little out of place anyways, It wasnt in the books, and even Kristen Stewart admitted in the commentary that it could give people the impression that Bella is with Edward so that she could become a vampire, which Kristen 発言しました (and I agree) isnt true. Bella is becoming a vampire to be with Edward, it is just that she is lucky enough that both parts,( being with Edward and becoming a vampire), are also what is right for her.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
samvarshiniraja said:
yeah it would be if they could make him !!!
but how?????
its well known they cant suck the vemon out of his body(duh)then how????????
i think bella being changed into a vampire would make sense cos let tat muddle head be beautiful at least in tat life
bella doesnt want her life to be told as miserable によって rosalie tats y she told her its not miserable
but i think its not miserable .seriously havin 2 hot guys loving u doesnt happen to any girl but the thing i really find sad is both of them being madly in 愛 with someone like bella ?????
(i mean the character and not kristen)
anyways it would be nice to have human edward and it would have been much much better if he loved someone worthier than bella
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
Angrykittykj said:
Flaw? I don't think so. I think Bella was saying that her life wasn't miserable BECAUSE she had Edward and the Cullens. Before they came into it, yeah, she did have a miserable life. She didn't have any friends, she missed her mother, didn't understand her father and was living in a town she hated. When Bella says her life isn't miserable, she isn't talking about having Angela and Mike for friends.

So, no, I don't see your logic. And yes, I think she was mature enough to make the decision. Sometimes あなた just know what あなた want and it is the best thing for you. Stephenie even 発言しました in an interview that she doesn't think most 18 年 olds are mature enough to make the decisions that Bella did, but that Bella is a FICTIONAL CHARACTER and that her situation is different. Besides... having Edward and Bella both be human is soooooo boring. I'm sorry, but if あなた remove the fantastical element from this series, all あなた have is a bunch of angst and that doesn't interest me at all. The series is perfect the way it is.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
next question »