この質問に回答する

トワイライト・シリーズ 質問

im just sayin'

i dont understand why people have to hate one of the characters in twilight for the stuff that they do! if they didnt do the stuff あなた hate them for then the story that we all know and 愛 would change completely!!! yeah あなた might disagree with what they did for example people hate jacob because he "got in bellas way" well if あなた were in 愛 with someone who wanted to be turned into your mortal enemy wouldnt あなた at least try to stop them?
*
well dont say
twilightrosefan posted 1年以上前
 sunset1444 posted 1年以上前
next question »

トワイライト・シリーズ  ベストアンサー

twilightdivinas said:
NO, i won't try to stop it, thats bella's ecision and i dont get why jacod think that bella once change xhe was gonna be her enemy? Two differnt people can still be フレンズ but no hes selfish and want bella to choose him.....and jacod is stupid, i think he never 愛 bella he just wanna bother Edward......and if he wouldnt get on bella's way well idk i care that he don;t leave edward. Now he 発言しました he imprint on renesmee what about if renesmee choose someone else and get merry and have a daughter i think that stupid would 発言しました he loves renesmee daugther, and so on....so no i think he still the same idiot as always :P
select as best answer
 NO, i won't try to stop it, thats bella's ecision and i dont get why jacod think that bella once change xhe was gonna be her enemy? Two differnt people can still be フレンズ but no hes selfish and want bella to choose him.....and jacod is stupid, i think he never 愛 bella he just wanna bother Edward......and if he wouldnt get on bella's way well idk i care that he don;t leave edward. Now he 発言しました he imprint on renesmee what about if renesmee choose someone else and get merry and have a daughter i think that stupid would 発言しました he loves renesmee daugther, and so on....so no i think he still the same idiot as always :P
posted 1年以上前 
*
best answer im so agree with u
twilightrosefan posted 1年以上前
next question »

回答

mandapanda said:
No disrespect, but people are going to have opinions. That's life and you're just going to have to deal with it.

People have negative opinions about Jacob and about Edward. People hate Edward and people hate Jacob. True, the things they do that people hate are what makes the story what it is, but あなた can't yell at people for liking または disliking certain characters.

One thing about Twilight that is so great is that the characters are relatable. Maybe the reader disagrees with a character's act because they personally see it as wrong? Maybe because of how they were brought up and raised? Their beliefs? または maybe because something similar happened to them [the reader] in their life? Most people have reasons for disliking a character because of what they have learned and gathered in their life.

And, in no way did Jacob "get in the way" of Bella and Edward's relationship. He never caused Bella to doubt her 愛 for Edward. And, from how the 本 were written, I don't understand how anyone could think Bella would leave Edward to be with Jacob at the end of Eclipse. They went through Twilight and New Moon, and Eclipse together. They went "to hell" (their separation in New Moon) and back again (when they were reunited), they're engaged... From an unbiased point of view, I really can't see how anyone would think Bella would have chosen Jacob. It's just that all the facts lead up to Edward.

And the way he tried to stop her wasn't the correct way. He disrespected Bella and Edward によって キス her without her permission. He made her feel bad in certain situations as well.

And, this thought just occurred to me... Edward didn't want Bella to change. He would do anything for her to stay human. He left didn't he. People hated him for that. And just like Jacob, he did what he thought was right... he wanted her to stay human. Therefore, if he was out of her life, there would be no reason to become what he is.

But it's not their decision. It's Bella's. And people fail to realize that. In real life, people are saying "It's their life. Why should it matter if they smoke?" Well, it's Bella's life. Why should it matter if she turns to a vampire? She would be happy. And if あなた 愛 someone enough, あなた would want them to be happy, even if that means having to sacrifice what あなた want for them.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Thank あなた for saying that so the rest of us don't have to. <3
musiclikelove posted 1年以上前
*
:)
mandapanda posted 1年以上前
*
True, it's strange to hate a fictional character :) But then again, it's strange to fall in 愛 with them. And, well I hope that my answer could provide somewhat of an answer for あなた on why people would choose to like または dislike them. :)
mandapanda posted 1年以上前
foxykitty136 said:
yeah thats true,and u have a point,BUT he did キッス Bella and she din't like it, and Edward was almost gonna kill him.

select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
yeah but thats one of my お気に入り parts in the book, its so funny!!
sunset1444 posted 1年以上前
*
Me too sunset1444!! I was laughing so hard!!
Mommy2Kalila posted 1年以上前
*
NO, it's not funny thats what ruin the book and movie
twilightdivinas posted 1年以上前
Emmalie1935 said:
I still don't like Jacob, I'm just sayin. :D
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
lauracullen66 said:
its true- the choices the characters make are what defines the series
but there are going to be people who disagree with those choice and thats why they dislkie a character. Not every character is going to be totally liked によって everyone- thats just human nature
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
next question »