この質問に回答する

塔の上のラプンツェル 質問

Do あなた think Gothel was Evil?

link

^ I read this on IMDB.com
and I found it interesting.

あなた don't have to read it all, but read the original poster. Do あなた think Gothel was evil? または do あなた think she kinda cared for Rapunzel?

Please give explanation.
 lolquack posted 1年以上前
next question »

塔の上のラプンツェル 回答

juniper427 said:
Evil is almost non-exsistant. I very rarely use the word.

Gothel was undeniable a very bad person. But much like Flyn was a good person who could do bad things, Gothel was a bad person who could do good things. There are no evil people または good people, there are just people with different levels of good and evil.

Nevertheless I found her to be a very interesting and satisfying villein.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
firegirl1515 said:
SPOILERS AHEAD! DO NOT CONTINUE IF あなた HAVEN'T SEEN TANGLED!




While that post did bring up some valid points, I still disagree. The King and クイーン didn't decide to withhold the flower- all the citizens willingly went out in 検索 of it in the prologue, and no one seemed to be forced. Gothel had probably lived at least 50 lifetimes before the 花 was needed to save the queen. She was old- she should've eventually accepted death and 与えられた up on the flower, または better yet, never used it in the first place. The クイーン was young, and was with child- no one in the kingdom wanted her または the baby to die, and so they went out to look for the flower. Perhaps everyone knew stories of the flower, but it's location must've died out with the original inhabitants of the area. Gothel was obviously the only one who knew where it was, and she quite selfishly kept it hidden. Of course she didn't intend to steal herself a child- she wanted a lock of hair. But the fact that she ストール, 盗んだ a newborn baby from it's cradle, fully knowing how much everyone loved her, proves Gothel evil enough. Then there were the lenghts she went to to keep herself alive when Rapunzel could've been helping the sick of her kingdom. She locked Rapunzel in an aptly-hidden tower and lied about the whole world to her face. And then, even after 18 years, she refused to let her go. Then she was going to keep her chained up in some undisclosed location, right after stabbing Rapunzel's one true love.

あなた can't say Gothel isn't evil to an extent IMO. However, I do believe she liked Rapunzel, about the same amount that Zira cared about Nuka in The Lion King 2. No one 発言しました あなた couldn't care about something when you're evil- look at Maleficent and Diablo.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
I actually think her whole "caring for Rapunzel" thing was just a way to manipulate her. If she liked her it was like little to none. I think it was just a way of controlling her. But YES, I see what youre saying xD
lolquack posted 1年以上前
soxfan89 said:
Well, She Seemed Kind Of Caring. But She Was Pure Evil!
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
gbug4ever said:
If she really cared about Rapunzel, she would let her be happy. Remember how she took her away from Flynn and cut her off from her family?
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
iandamonfan said:
She's evil! IF she cared about something, it was Rapunzel's hair and nothing else.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
next question »