Dean has been to Hell! How much worse could it get!

^^ Just what i as thinking D= Awww my poor Dean! <33

Sorry, Sam, but you just can't top 40 years in hell!

I had a hard time with this one because I think both of them had a horrible time. Yes, Dean was in Hell for 40 years, 10 of which he was forced to torture others, but...Sam had to try and live without Dean, confused by his growing powers, and guilt-ridden because he knows it's because of him that Dean is in Hell in the first place. In my opinion, both had it equally as bad, just in different ways.

Hello....... sam has lost his mother, his girlfriend, his brother, his father what more could he loose, he even had to kill maddison the werewolf!!! i think he has suffored more then dean.

yeah but Dean has also lost his mother, his father, his brother (the stanford period, when Sam died, when he was going to hell and had to leave Sam), and he let Cassie, Jo, Lisa and Ben go to protect them from his life ... both of them have lost a lot of people.

and then add the 4 months (40 years!) in hell on top of that.

Plus Dean has had to keep more secrets and had more responsibilities placed on him than Sam.

i agree with tinkerbell1992 sam has lost more thain dean

can't possibly decide