この質問に回答する

セブルス・スネイプ 質問

Snape is the only death eater able to produce a full patronus which had a definite shape(a doe). Why the other death eaters can't produce a full patronus? I read it in HP Wikipedia.

 Bibelot posted 1年以上前
next question »

セブルス・スネイプ 回答

lilyZ said:
Because Snape wasn't a real Death Eater! OK, he was a Death Eater at the beginning, but after Voldemort killed Lily, he came on Dumbledore's side and he saved almost everyone he could.
select as best answer
 Because Snape wasn't a real Death Eater! OK, he was a Death Eater at the beginning, but after Voldemort killed Lily, he came on Dumbledore's side and he saved almost everyone he could.
posted 1年以上前 
LadyNottingham said:
He could produced a Patronus because he knew what 愛 was. 愛 is the most powerful positive emotion ever (no matter if that 愛 is painful または not). Therefore, Severus was able to produce it.
Honestly, can あなた imagine Lucius Malfoy または Bellatrix Lestrange producing one ?! They just mean it when it comes to make suffer.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
inkdancer457 said:
Severus can conjure a patrounus because he's not really a deatheater. Deatheaters can't conjure a patrounus (I assume) because they have no good in them, no happiness, and no love. Only greed and ambition.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
StainlessSteel said:
He's considered the only Death Eater capable of having emotions and happy memories.(How ironic is that?!)
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
bri-marie said:
I think it was because, ironically, he knew what true 愛 and happiness were. He, unlike the other Death Eaters had emotions and happy memories.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
Faith-Rulz said:
Yeah exactly LilyZ~!
Also i reckon cuz Lily was a 情報源 of happy memory in alot of ways while i think the Death Eaters on Voldemorte's side in some ways ロスト all their true positive-happy feelings yknow...
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
Brysis said:
To produce a full Patronus あなた have to full your mind with happy things, with the persons あなた love, the things that makes yous happy. Severus thought about Lily but the other Death Eaters didn´t had nothing "happy" to think about.
Dead?
Voldemort?
NOT HAPPY
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
illo said:
I think he waz a death eater cuz in hp 4 serious tells Harry tat a death nevever quits being one...
Bt the reason he could produse a patronous waz becaz he had happy memories whereas the other death eaters happy memories were clouded によって fear of voldemort and cruelness.they could hav had good memories bt tat would hav been of torturing または killing someone so they really cnt be happy memories...
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
snapeislove said:
well, they cant think of something happy.. that's all.. patronuses are for good hearts..
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
popo6 said:
Because the death eater doesn't know what's real happiness their whole life they have been killing people and they live in fear cuz of Voldemort xD
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
Brigidme said:
Severus could produce a patronus because he loves. When producing a patronus one must think of something which brings a happy feeling. Death Eaters do not understand joy and happiness. Dumbledore 発言しました " Severus is no もっと見る a death eater than I am"
select as best answer
 Severus could produce a patronus because he loves. When producing a patronus one must think of something which brings a happy feeling. Death Eaters do not understand joy and happiness. Dumbledore 発言しました " Severus is no もっと見る a death eater than I am"
posted 1年以上前 
next question »