Honestly she shouldn't have been mad, or even surprised that Nathan and Brooke slept together... considering both of their pasts, and the kind of teens that they both used to be.
But I do think she had a right to be upset that neither of them ever told her. Especially since Baley are supposed to be such "amazing" friends (as some people claim). I don't think Haley would have really cared, if they were just upfront, and honest about it. But sleeping with one of your friends' husbands, or one of your wife's friends is a pretty big deal, and something that that person deserves to know. Whether it happened a long time ago, or meant anything or not. That's just something that someone deserves to be in the know about lol. I sure wouldn't want to find out about it the same way that Haley did.
usually i think haley does tend to overreact, and be overly critical about things. but not in this case. thats a pretty big thing that atleast ONE of them should have had the decency to tell her about
Absolutely not. Though Haley was aware of the kind of person Nathan(and Brooke) was before she married Nathan, the fact that he had a fling with one of her best friends is something worth mentioning. Regardless of the stupidity of the occurrence,he had broken her trust. Now she didn't dwell on it for a long time so I honestly don't see how she overreacted in this situation. Now the Carrie storyline and the Renee Scandal ...YES she overreacted.
Well, I think she had a right to be upset...I mean your husband or one of your best friends not telling you that they once slept together has to be pretty tough, especially when you find out like Haley did. But on the other hand, Haley did overreact a little bit. Of course she knew what kind of person Nathan used to be! Hell, he even lost his virginity to her sister! And I don't really see a difference there...both Brooke and Taylor were (well, Taylor still kind of is :D) basically sluts back then and it's not like it was some big mystery to Haley. Besides, it's not even something Nathan could tell her during breakfast! "Oh, by the way, there's one thing you should know about me: I slept with Brooke and we made a sextape!" It happened once when Nathan was still a complete jackass. Just like it happened with Taylor. And I guess it's not even Haley's place to overreact considering they weren't even together back then! Sure, she has a right to be mad about it but I guess Peyton was the one who had a right to be overly furious (and she kind of was xD). She and Nathan weren't even broken up at that point and he just moved on to Brooke the same night Peyton and Nathan had that fight!
Agree with Lisiii
Seriously it's crap to be upset with your best friend that she didn't tell you that when you weren't friends you had sex with her husband and you taped it.If Brooke DID tell her before the tape being reavealed Haley would have still been upsed and just go:"Why did you tell?Are you trying to tell me something else?"and so on.
No. First off Haley didn't know either Brooke or Nathan during the sextape scandal. Second, it was one of the last things on either Brooke or Nathan's mind, so why mention it. Third, when is a good time to tell your wife or close friend that you slept with someone they are very close with? Besides if Brooke would have said something, I'm almost 100% sure that her haters would have attacked her for stirring up the past and ruing Naley bliss.
Honestly she shouldn't have been mad, or even surprised that Nathan and Brooke slept together... considering both of their pasts, and the kind of teens that they both used to be.
But I do think she had a right to be upset that neither of them ever told her. Especially since Baley are supposed to be such "amazing" friends (as some people claim). I don't think Haley would have really cared, if they were just upfront, and honest about it. But sleeping with one of your friends' husbands, or one of your wife's friends is a pretty big deal, and something that that person deserves to know. Whether it happened a long time ago, or meant anything or not. That's just something that someone deserves to be in the know about lol. I sure wouldn't want to find out about it the same way that Haley did.
Seriously it's crap to be upset with your best friend that she didn't tell you that when you weren't friends you had sex with her husband and you taped it.If Brooke DID tell her before the tape being reavealed Haley would have still been upsed and just go:"Why did you tell?Are you trying to tell me something else?"and so on.
ファンポップにサインインまたは登録してコメントを追加する