{#3/Episode acting} Who acted the best in 3x16? アンケート Results - ワン・トゥリー・ヒル

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

ワン・トゥリー・ヒル {#3/Episode acting} Who acted the best in 3x16?

104 fans picked:

Peyton

52%

Brooke

35%

Haley

11%

Lucas

Nathan

no votes yet

Jessica4695 posted １年以上前

Make your pick! | next poll >>

32 comments

	kellyerin87 picked Peyton: No contest. AMAZING. posted １年以上前.

	carambolas picked Peyton: Agreed! posted １年以上前.

	TheBoySawAComet picked Peyton: duh. hilarie was the only one who even had any challenging scenes to act in this episode... and she nailed every bit of it <3 posted １年以上前.

	babe1492 picked Haley: So she got shot in the foot, so what. I think Bethany was much better. Sophia too. posted １年以上前.

	TheBoySawAComet picked Peyton: ^ a) she was shot in the LEG. b) because of that, she had to spend basically the whole episode crying, acting terrified, mentally and physically drained, and truly scared for her life. and she did all of it flawlessly the work that any of the other actors had to do in this episode doesn't even compare, in terms of difficulty. except for jimmy, ofcourse... or abby. but they're not options, so... posted １年以上前. last edited １年以上前

	hhw picked Peyton: ^^ Agree posted １年以上前.

	gizem4 picked Lucas: I really liked chad's acting in this episode =) posted １年以上前.

	mooshka picked Peyton: Honestly, I don't even see how the others are even an option. Hilarie had the toughest role to play and she pulled it off beautifully, She did some amazing acting this episode. posted １年以上前.

	livexthexlife92 picked Brooke: there is a deleted scene where brooke is at the gym and shes talking to a reporter. i think its prob one of sophias best performances on the show to date. i wish theyd kept it in there. posted １年以上前.

	energizerbunny picked Peyton: Sophia is always great, but imo Hilarie's part was harder in this specific episode. =] But all of them are great actors/actresses =] posted １年以上前. last edited １年以上前

	kellyerin87 picked Peyton: ^^ Yeah, I've seen that deleted scene. I heard all the raving about it, and it made me want to see it. So my sister and I specifically watched it, just to see what all the fuss was about. And at the end of it, we both looked at each other like "So? What's the big deal?" lol. So that scene still doesn't change my choice. And it's good, don't get me wrong. But I still think people just give Sophia way too much credit, for simply doing her job. There's acting, and then there's going above, and beyond just simply reading lines. And in this episode (deleted scenes, and all)... I personally feel that Hilarie is the only one who not only acted, but surpassed what was expected of her. Just my opinion, though. posted １年以上前. last edited １年以上前

	bdavisrocks picked Haley: They were all great, but Joy is always just WOW :) posted １年以上前.

	Leytonfan4ever picked Peyton: "No I can't walk.. I tried." "Please don't leave me.. PLEASE." ^^ Amazing. Peyton was suppose to look & feel scared/hurt, and Hilarie DEFIANTLY pulled it off! Way better than I expected. Bethany is defiantly next. posted １年以上前. last edited １年以上前

	delenadarti picked Peyton: i'm sorry bit i think the scene when brooke started to cry was really stupid posted １年以上前.

	leytonfaan_18 picked Peyton: because of that, she had to spend basically the whole episode crying, acting terrified, mentally and physically drained, and truly scared for her life. and she did all of it flawlessly Agreed. Hilarie was amazing<33 posted １年以上前.

	Lisiii picked Peyton: I think they all did an incredible job in this episode! But I agree with you guys...Hilarie definitely had the hardest part and the way she portrayed the pain and fear Peyton must've felt in that moment is beyond amazing <3 posted １年以上前.

	CharmedFan4eva_ picked Peyton: all did great but this was a 'peyton' episode. posted １年以上前.

	truffethedog picked Brooke: That scene that this icon is from is one of my fave scenes in OTH ever. SB just nails it. posted １年以上前.

	Drisina picked Peyton: Her scene(s) with Lucas made me stop on the program OTH was on and watch the whole episode. posted １年以上前.

	MsScott picked Peyton: even though i love nathan and his whole hero thing going in to save haley...peyton was heartbraking, beautiful... posted １年以上前.

	Leyton4ever picked Brooke: I really can't stand any season where Hilarie has to cry...she is AWFUL at it. posted １年以上前.

	kellyerin87 picked Peyton: I really can't stand any season where Hilarie has to cry...she is AWFUL at it. What?!? lol she is one of the only actors who CAN actually cry. Like legit sheds tears. I think she is by far the best crier on the show :) posted １年以上前.

	energizerbunny picked Peyton: ^Agreed.Hilarie's crying is very underrated to me. People seem to love Brooke's crying, and hate Hilarie's. Brooke's crying is good, but she never sheds a tear. :/ Bethany would be next for me.Even she had a harder part that Sophia lol I know it seems like I'm bashing her, but I'm not.She always does great, but this episode didn't really seem that challenging for her part as the others. posted １年以上前. last edited １年以上前

	Leytonfan4ever picked Peyton: ^ Brooke has shed a tear. If you watch the BL letter scene closely (yes, I have watched it, lol) you can see that Brooke shed a tear or even in 3x22 when she was arguing with Lucas, she shed a tear. posted １年以上前.

	kellyerin87 picked Peyton: ^ Yes, she has... although I don't remember seeing any tears in her 3x22 fight with Lucas. But more often then not, she doesn't. She usually just goes through the crying motions, without actually crying. This pic is a perfect example of what we usually see from Brooke lol. She makes the faces, her eyes MAY get slighly watery, the make-up crew makes her nose red (lol)... but she's not REALLY crying :/ link posted １年以上前. last edited １年以上前

	Leytonfan4ever picked Peyton: ^ Oh.. I was talking about just shedding a tear. Not full on, eyes puffy, cheeks wet kind of thing. Because then I would say that I haven't seen Brooke in THAT kind of way. As for the 3x22, I haven't seen in a while, but I do remember like a single tear coming down. Plus, in the commentary (for that scene or that episode), it was said that during rehearsal, tears kept coming out, so I'm pretty sure she did shed a tear in that scene. I don't know. Maybe it's just me :/ posted １年以上前. last edited １年以上前

	kellyerin87 picked Peyton: Yeah, I'm talking about tears too lol. My point was that in THAT pic, she LOOKS like she may be crying, and shedding tears... but she usually isn't. I dunno... I've personally just always thought that people give her way too much credit, in that aspect of her acting. posted １年以上前.

	annoulla picked Brooke: Nobody is higher(for me)of Brooke.She is the one<3 posted １年以上前.

	RoswellGirl13 picked Brooke: i thought they were all amazing. but the guy that plays Jimmy was great! posted １年以上前.

	Bangel90 picked Peyton: Sophia always does an awesome job but I was very touched by Hilarie in this episode (the nearly dying thing always gets me) posted １年以上前.

	svety74 picked Peyton: Hilarie did one hell of a job in this episode. She played Peyton perfectly. I could feel the emotions she wanted to trasmit especially when she says to Lucas, 'No. I can't. I can't walk. I tried' & 'No don't leave me please' However everyone did a great job :) posted １年以上前.

	Nicolas97 picked Peyton: No contest, she was stunningly great in this episode! Chad, James & Bethany were average but maybe because they weren't given a big part... I'm gonna hate me for saying that because it is one of my favorite episodes for Brooke but Sophia's crying scene seemed really forced! She played the anxious girl that had no idea what was happening and was very scared quite well in the rest of the episode. posted １年以上前.