Ofcourse brooke.she was always better friend than peyton.and i love her.so i'm in her side:P

Brooke of course!!

Peyton for sure 100% - i wrote a lengthy response when this was first asked as to why - and it's not because Peyton is my favourite it's because Peyton is in the right.

Peyton was way more right!
Brooke was hurt but nobody has the right to make fun of your dead mum and MORE when she was with Peyton and knew how much it hurt!
Brooke acted like an immature bitch and I was glad Peyton told her that she didn't care anymore!

I would be on both sides equally BUT Brooke dissapointed me !!

eeeexactly!

TEAM BROOKE!!!! DEFINATELY!!!!!! peyton has hurt brooke sooo many times !!!!! more than anyone! she's a backstabbing bitch!
and she replied to brooke:
Peyton: Well in that case, I love you, Brooke
is that kinder?? she almost said i want you to die!!!

brooke wanted honesty from Peyton when she wasn't honest with her . and it seemed like brooke didn't even plan to tell her. Peyton heard her a lot of times -yes . but that proves that brooke isn't an angel.

woah, this question will reopen old debates :(

I'm not in the mood to talk about this again :P

maybe later?

this scene reminded me yet again why i can't stand brooke...brooke is a selfish immature bitch and this scene is one that showcases it best...of course most of the time i just think she's selfish and immature..but this time she was beyond ridiculous....
and anyway this was a long time ago...now i just think she's selfish....so thats an improvement...but well i still cant stand her.

I could see Peyton's point and what she said is true but i have a tendency to take Brooke's side in the Breyton fight i guess because she is my fav and i love her so much and abs is right this is gonna open the flood gates.

irene_p: 'Well in that case, I love you, Brooke
is that kinder?? she almost said i want you to die!!! '

is that not kind really? didnt know! so what is -
'if you love me your gonna die soon, see mothers one and two' .. yeah sure she had a problem with peyton - but you NEVER EVER bring up people you have lost - that hurts way too much! its worse than telling her to go die! of course she didnt mean what she said (peyton) .. but you can never take back calling a moms death! i mean when peyton said that she smiled and gave a kiss - she was messing around! she needed a quick come back and she got one!! and im not even talking about the basketball game - i didnt care - what got me was the car scene! peyton never replied to that - she just had a mini slap fight!

'you made fun of my moms death brooke, you cried with me when she died, now you use it as a punch line to one of your jokes to hurt me' .. i say good on peyton!

brooke was the hypocrit- peyton made the best points - brooke just rebelled in a brooke like manner!

i still ♥ both though!

***pasted from a poll***

"It was piled up emotion of realizing that brooke slept with nathan, never had any intention of telling her the truth, and then cut peyton out/slapped her/made her life a living hell for telling the truth - not to mention peyton found out in front of half the school. I'd understand if brooke slapped/punched peyton after she found out about her and luke in s1. but peyton telling brooke the truth, and putting her foot in her mouth doesn't warrant a slap. What brooke did and how peyton found out infront of EVERYONE is understandably upsetting so I can understand peyton's actions (though I never agree that violence is the answer :P)"

^ Soooo true!

This is tough a question, but Peyton had some right to anger since Brooke made her feel so bad. But at the same time she and Nathan were so toxic, so Brooke really did a favor.

I think Peyton was more mad that Brooke kept secrets from her, than that she shagged Nathan, I mean everyone back then shagged Nathan. Peyton knew that, she just never expected her BF to, hoes over bros and all.

But Peyton got over it. And they are strong as ever, I say we embrace that.

as much as i love brooke more than peyton i deffo was on peytons side mocking peytons moms was lowest of the lows if i was peyton i would of ripped her hair out and totally kicked her ass. after all the grief she gave peyton for kissing lucas she SLEPT with nathan yeh they were younger and drunk etc and they were always breaking up it was low for brooke

Team Peyton!

THANK YOU LIVELOVELAUGH!! even the biggest Brooke fan should be able to admit that Brooke was wrong in this situation. SHE MADE FUN OF HER PEYTON'S MOM'S DEATH!!!! she cut Peyton out for being honest while she never intended on telling her about her and Nathan. And even if Nathan was a bad guy and Pathan's relationship was toxic, CHEATING IS CHEATING. i don't go around making excuses for what Leyton did to Brooke in s1, and i can at least admit that is wrong eventhough i am a huge Leytoner.

CHEATING IS CHEATING, and this situation makes Brooke especially wrong because it makes her a hypocrite. and i am honestly not saying this because Peyton is my favorite character..even if i were a HUGE Brooke fan/Peyton hater, i would know that Peyton was right.

I agree with all the people who picked Peyton!!!

I was totally on P. Sawyer's side cuz well brooke slpet with Nathan and never said a word but when peyton kissed Lucas she treated like a backstabing two faced bitch and cut her out of her life when she (brooke) did something worst than that!!! Then she made fun of her death mom's, you can't do that...not even to your worst enemy, that's the lowest thing brooke ever done. Im not sure why peyton forgave her!
and then miss Brooke decides that is Petyon's fault that Chase leave her..wtf?! Brooke sweetie, you are the one who slept eith nathan and cheated on your best friend if Chase leave you is because of that...hello!!?

I just remember why i hated brooke so much! Im hating her again...hypocrite backstabing slut!!!

Lol, what everyone else said^^. I also see Brooke's side but think she was a little more in the wrong.

i hate peyton so much grrr i hope she dies for spoiling brucas's relationship =[
go brucas !!!

i totally agree with you livelovelaugh! ;)

let me just say i completely disagree with mehrajanwar and i think it's a little pathetic that you lash out like that. this isn't a Peyton vs. Brooke fight..this is just a question of who was right in this particular situation.

don't insult us by saying that stuff, it makes you look really immature.

Brooke SLEPT with Nathan FIRST,before Leyton KISSED! Yet made Peyton out to be a two faced backstabbing b****! Then Brooke made fun of the death of her mom's! Peyton had every right to come back with, "Well in that case, I love you, Brooke" she was asking for it! Everybody that picked Brooke is biased,they only picked her because they love her sooooo much! In fact,I believe thats WHY they are BRUCAS FANS! Cut the strings, link

i agree ^^

haha mehrajanwarfgdij
you know we don't get on.

just be quiet, we've heard it all before.
AND LOOK AROUND YOU, even some of the biggest brucas fans understood and supported peyton in this! so get over it!

i hadn't actually read your paragraph there... but that's low mehrakdihvdf. seriously, trying to act like lila or saBrucas and the fewreally randomly offensive people is not cool, cause you'll always end up like lila.

BANNED!

I ABsoultly agree with people who pick peyton:D
in that season, i was so mad of brooke,to what she said about peyton"s moms,and that nathan thing

lmfaoo amy!

end up like lila BANNED!! ROFL!

hahahah love you Amy!!
he is going to end up like his idol Lila
soo out of here!!!

OHH CALM DOWNN JEZZZ SOO TOUCHYY THESE DAYSS :|

Okay guys seriously leave him alone. He might have been a little harsh but that's his opinion. It's not like you don't bash occasionally. Just please lay off.

Man the last couple days have been touchy the last two days and i agree with Alice

Brooke forsure. she was angry and hurting and wen pple r like tht they say things in the heat of the moment nd i undestand her situation. but yea if brooke was at fault then peyton was soo, she practically said she wanted brooke to die. but watevs peyton always has to be the victim. its just pathetic.

mehrajanwar one of my problems with you it's that you can't express your opionion in a normal civil way!!! why you have always to insult the other fanbase???
I'm sure you know what my problem is...dont be an hypocrite

seroiusly u gotta stop this no one can say what they fell anymore abt btw alessandra_28 like leytoners dont do it to us or peytoners they unsult others just the same so lay off

ARE YOU KIDDING?
There comments insulting Peyton with the WORST way and we STILL try to be civilised something that you don't! If in a comment I was saying "BROOKE IS A SLUT WHO NEEDS TO DIE AND BURN IN HELL" I AM SURE all of you would have EATEN ME ALIVE..SO YOU SHOULD GET OVER IT..If you don't want to get reported and banned all the time..CAUSE MANY OF YOU HAVE BEEN BOTH GO TO YOU SPOT AND INSULT PEYTON BUT HERE NOOOOOOOO!! Sorry but It's just so annoying that you can't see the reality!

mehraj don't listen to them! who cares what they think! lol... Chloe(SaBrucas) is amazing she has great reasons why she loves bl!

as for me i think it was wrong of brooke to say the dead moms thing! it's horrible!
but i had to go with brooke not because i hate peyton!( i actually i don't hate peyton i just don't like mark! i just don't really like the way her wrote that character)but because peyon was being horrible.. i thought it was wrong how she was fighting with Brooke about sleeping with Nathan when they were broken up, while peyton has cheated on people a number of times!!!! (i know it still kinda counts as cheating) but peyton and nathan were never in love! peyton did this more than once!!!!!!! Brooke was in love with lucas in season 1 and peyton knew that but she still went for lucas, than she promised brooke she wouldn't do it again... and when Brooke and lucas are in love again she has to come between them! it thought brooke had every right to be hurt...... and im not blaming peyton for the bl break up! im just saying im on brookes side!

In the fight of s1: Brooke was right, Peyton was wrong. In s3: Peyton was right, Brooke was wrong. In s4: i agree with both actually

meharwar or whatever your name is I naver mention sabrucas in my coment cuz I dont know her, I dont talk about people IDk and specially not behin there backs like you...I still remember what you wrote about me...the next time tell it to ME!!!!
and jennifer, I know lpers talk like that too but you (all brucasers) never do something to stop them and you cant blame us for stop or defend ourselves when someone insults us even if the person already delete the post...what a cougar!!!

^^ what did she say about you?

omg people get a life!!! [yawns]* bored of this shit!

Hannah he said in a brucas poll that Im annoying and arrogant and that he wished Lila still her so she could kick my ass and that i was the worst lper!!
but w/e he will be banned soon so I dont care anymore!

yeah I said that cuz she was rude

and I said to herI wasnt talking behin her back
and I dont see nothing wrong saying that I dont like her..I know she is devoted that's what I picked her

just like to point out im on ale and amys side here! cos mehrajanwar started it by her 'inappropriate' comment - and totally flipped at the next bad thing said! i f you dont want no people jumping down your back dont write any comments like that - i dont anymore - well unless i WANT a fight! ive learnt it- now you need to!

and what the hell - yeah we get sabrucas and lila are great people or whatever - you like them! so why you being so touchy?

to top this off i just looked at ales comment and why you having a go at her? she just repeated amy! ... just like i did! why have a go at her and not me? OMG soo confused!

BTW ale just told me about your little emails ... lila wannabee! your tryna be her all bitchy on the front - yeah its not working! she was awesome at it ... you not soo much!

okay i don't know what mehraj said before.. but i think this fight is getting a bit stupid! i think we should just let it go! Chloe is a very devoted bl fan just like the rest of us blers.. as for this fight i think it's gotten way out of hand! im so sick of insulting fans thing! thats when i get mad...sry for my rant i don't want this comment to be mean or anything but i think.. i just really don't want another bl vs lp war

im not even fighting for bl vs lp! i dont care what she said TBH! im defending my friends! if you dont like it tough shit!

FTWinnage! I ROCK!

laurra im not getting mad cause your defending your friends! don't you see im doing the same thing! im not evena mad! im just saying theres no reason for anyone to get banned over a stupid little fight! all i was saying is i don't want this to turn into a major bl vs lp fan war where everyone hates each other.. idk if you took my comment as negative but i was supposed to be the other way around!

i never took it negative lol dont worry :) if anything ill make sure you dont get banned hehe! xD

im only here to step in cos it looked like 2 vs 1 - cos amy isnt online it was just ale! like a liccle peace maker gone wrong me! :D haha mean well but i just make arguments bigger! WOO!

lol why would i get banned??

ohh and i wasn't taking sides! im just trying to spread some peace.. i mean it's almost christmas! wheres the holiday cheer?? lol.. im so corny!

haha i dnno - but ales angry she could report every user on this page haha you never know! i could get reported for being on ales side - ya never know ;)

hahaha...lol

i dont know what aspergers syndrome is! but ok just calm down!

THIS MAKES ME LOL

look, mehraj, i'm sorry you have aspergers syndrome but it's not very nice to use it as an excuse in an argument like this.
although it must be horrible, it's not nice to use it against us.

aww im so sry mehraj! Laurra: link

ok people we should stop doing this!!
You all know I never had a problem with anyone in fanpop I dont like to fight cuz after all its a tv show and i dont come here to fight...I was just defending myself but seriously I dont want to fight anymore it's pointless!!
and I'm not angry Laura and I wont report anyone...I cant say I didnt report Mehraj after what he wrote about me and after he wrote that post he delete when he insulted Peyton and Peytons fans but Im not going to report him because this cuz you already said it IT'S STUPID!!!
lets just move on and be happy lol

I never heard that song before...Im just not a Britney fan anymore, I liked her like 10 years ago haha
I love DC...it's my favorite show!!!

omg this is so funny! mehraj sorry to say i can't stand britney

omg i love lost!

It's ok Mehraj, I'm sorry about all things i said too lol
I only watched Gilmore Girls once and I didt like it...not my type of show, to be honest Im not a big fan of tv.
I only watch OTH and when I have the time and i remember it I watch gossip girl or grey's anatomy but mostly i forgot about it.
Lost...I never watched that show either lol

basically the only shows Im really a fan are Dawson's Creek and OTH, the other I jsut watch them ramdomly

ohh my sister was addicted to gilmore girls! everyone loved that show!! i was like teh only person who couldn't stand it! they talk way too fast and are really annoying..lol...
Ale lost is soooooo good.. my number 1 favorite show! than i love prison break... i was watching gg's until jenny starting pissing me off but i heard she's leaving! so i might start again!

ohh i forgot oth SPOILERs: i heard Nathan asked to get killed off cause he's not making as much money as everyone else.. idk if this is true but it's just what i heard! i would def cry

Nathan is leaving!!!???
he should take Jamie with him and Mouth too!!!
They are my three least favorite chracters...
you must find wreid that i dont like Nathan but this bball storyline is soo boring and getting soooooooooooo old!! And James is't not a good actor at all, he cant show emotions. I use to love him but not anymore since s5 started.

and i love Jenny...the last episode I watch (the one when everyone visit Yale) she was great, i love her fashion and i loooove that thanks to her there rufly talked and rufus saw Lily what hot dress...haha

i know i loveeeeeeeeee nathan! i hope mouth goes and jamie is getting annoying! omg i would be so mad cause Nate is my favorite! but that would be so sad! i def think the bball story is getting soooooo old!

really rufus and lily! that would be sooo funny!

^^ totally agree Mehraj! omg i loveee himmm.. i would cry soooooooo hard!

whats DC?

Okay so I won't bother reading all your comments but I think things are fine now and I'm glad! Yay!

Hannah I think DC is Dawson's Creek.

And Ale you are funny!♥

brucas4ever, I read your reason for being on brooke's side. I won't try and change it, but I will clarify one of your reasons. You said peyton had no right to be mad about the nate thing, but she wasn't mad that brooke had a one night stand. It was the hypocricy of it all. That Brooke cut peyton out for not being honest with her in s1 - but when Peyton was honest with Brooke in s3 - she still cut peyton out. So coming to s4 - Peyton found out in front of everyone that Brooke was never EVER honest with Peyton. All that Brooke put peyton through in s4 was ill founded for Brooke did much worse (she wasn't honest at all - and had no intention of being honest).

i kinda agree they were never honest... but i felt like brooke was a totally different person when she was with nate.. but i agree neither of them were honest

^^that's why I dont like breyton so much...to much hipocricy coming for both sides I must say lol

and DC is Dawson's Creek...the best show i ever seen lol

and Mehraj I think it's ok to debate in civil way like abs was doing...not like we were doing yesterday lol

hahha toally agree ale i never been one of those huge breyton fans! but i liked them season 1-3

really???
I like them better in s5 and 6
all the hipocricy happens between those 3 seasons and well s4 too...no question about it!!!
they in list of least favorites...
my least fav is brathan, then braley and then breyton.

my favorites are laley, brathan, and baley

my least favs are breyton, brooke and mouth, and pathan

we deff have diferents tastes when it comes to oth!!!
neyton/pathan is my favorite friendship...I miss them soo much!!

lol my favorit thing is season 6 are the brathan scenes! im such a huge sophia/james shipper! its so funny! i always talk about breaking up naley for brathan! i would love them! i might even not care about leyton if i got a little brathan action!

I cant see the magic everyone sees in brathan...and I dont care about james and sophia...I dont ship real life couples, the only one I would ship is Chilarie!! Im obsses with them and their awesome chemistry on set and out of tjhe set lol
It's funny I wanted to break naley to have some neyton again...neyton with good nathan would be awesome!!! I would even stop shipping Leyton if I knew neyton have a chance!!!

wow! i would go for leyton if i could get any Brathan actioN!

wooow that's nathans sexy effect
aaaand he sitll my least fav lol
so bad we are wishing imposible things...what about if we kill haley? lol

ale, brucas4ever am I reading right??? I had no idea you two shipped different couples so strongly to the point that you'd let go of your favorited couples :P
lol. anyhow, brucas4ever I'm glad we found some common ground :)

and mehraj, I enjoy friendly debates. I have no intention of stirring things up. So no worries. I think brucas4ever and I are ok here, lol :)

NO WE CAN'T KILL HALEY OR NATHAN!

let's take into acount my feelings here cause i'm so amazing!
:):)


ok i kid.

but whatevs, naley STAYS!

and that's a bit unfair that James isn't getting paid as much as everyone else! i love him! i would marry him in a second. :)

THANK GOD WE AGREE ON SOME THINGS MEHRAJANWAR!!!!

NALEY FOREVER, AND BRATHAN IS CRAP! :):)

NO Mehraj! Brathan is love! don't you see the on screen connection! omg ive loved them ever since season 1 or 2! but ever since i first saw them! they're amazing!!!!!!!!! omgggg i would give up SHOPPING(got the idea from Nem) just to have a bit of brathan!..lol

LMAO!!!
I would give up leyton for neyton but shopping never!!!!
it's like give up eating!! no way lol
how could you like brathan in s1? the only convo between them that I can remember is...is...is...ok i got one when he aske her to put some ice on it.
IDK I cant see what you see!!!
I dont think Haley is ugly, actually I think she prettier than brooke.

lol.. thats why i said season 1 or 2 cause i couldn't think of any brathan season 1 ohh beside the party episode where brooke reads haleys letter but they looks so hott there! i don't think haley is ugly! i used to be i huge haley hater! then i started liking naley but now im like in love with brathan!

ohh yeah i was soo excited with all the brathan scenes this season! omg the one where nathan goes to see brooke! i was like soooo cute brathan are amazing!

lol i find brathan funny.

conversations

S1 - 'put some ice on it.' he's not interested.
'reading out letter.' she fucked things up with naley, he's angry.
trying to fix things with naley by setting them up on a date - clearly not wanting to be with him...
and i think that's about it.

S2 - emmm...
oh yeah, when nathan arrives at the party felix throws for brooke, but wait, he doesn't stay to talk to her, he just gets drink and leaves. WOW WHAT A CONNECTION!!
oh god, brooke kisses his cheek after he crashes!! THAT'S CRAZY LOVE!
oh and there are those scenes with them in nathan's dream. but it had to be that way cause it was an alternate universe... and oh they weren't real! :)
oh and she asks him how he gave up money to be poor...

S3 brooke goes to see Nathan and has some banter with him... but she's making sure he's going to the masquerade ball for HALEY!
she shouts at him for not paying attention to HALEY


S4 - oh god this created brathan.
the video - they were both drunk and had no idea what they were doing. they agreed it was a mistake and it should have been forgotten.
oh yeah that sprinkler scene.... CAME OUT OF THE BLUE! and it was probably to forshadow what was about to happen.

s5.... nope i didn't think so.

S6 - he's goes to tell her that she should let people in....


ok, i JUST DON'T GET IT AT ALL!!!!!! sorry if that was offensive i was just joking... but i hate them gads! sure they look good together... but that's about it!

and THANK YOU MEHRAJ! i totally agree with you!

and i just open the icon on paint or any image editor and then insert text into it! :)

Sorry for butting in but I really think something's weird with the Brathan friendship. lol

^^ join in Nem:] omg noooo one see's it but me! maybe theres smth wrong with me..lol.. kidding... i know they don't dont really have any scenes together loves-oth but i just love them.. i think they would be like th perfect couple!

and shut up Nem..lol..kidding.. Brathan frendship rocks!

hahahahahahahaha
Amy that was hilarious!!!
I feel the same about brathan...all I see there it's nothing!!!
But I understand you Hannah, I feel the same about Skeyton!! Im wreid I know! They only had a few scenes last season but Im in loveee with them and love that friendship that barely exists lol and I also think Peyton and skills could be the most perfect couple of history.
Skeyton= another couple that would make me forget my leyton love!!

friends dont hook up!!! Brathan are just people that know each other cuz they hang out with the same people and are part of the same social circle!! That's not friendship, never was and never will be!!
I totally dissagree on the brother/sister thing, I really hate when people say that because they have the same colour of hair...I hate when they say that about leyton cuz they dont look like sibbilings and either do brathan!! lol

breyton totall don't act let bro and sis! skeyton would be cute.. i think mouth and haley would be good together! they both always give the good guy good girl speeches!

ewwww poor Haley!!!
dont be mean!
Nobody deserves a punishment like that...being with Mouth eww!!
To be honest, I wanted Brooke and Mouth as a couple in s2 and s3...until Chase came in s4 <3 really even Gigi deserves better!!

hahah i can't stand mouth i hope he leaves for good! hes my least favorite person in the whole show!

brooke the bitch