ye i kinda just assumed it was the older brother who beat brooke up!

Yeah so did I ^^ it wasn't flat out said.. but I'm pretty sure thats what happened.

yes me too!!

Because he did not rob brooke Jack did but X killed Quietin .

yea the brother just killed Q because Sam's friend had to of attacked brooke because how else would Sam have gotten the designs. and the friend obviously likes sam so he would do anything for her and he thought she wanted brooke to hurt so yeah.

It only makes sense that X killed Q and didnt do nething else because sams friend introduced them and sam was kinda like uhh ok...so why would she have someone she doesn't know do it...so yea I think the friend attacked brooke

I really think the older brother did all!!
Sam told her friend Jack about Brooke, then Jack asked his brother to rob and beat up Brooke!! I never thought Jack did it, I was sure the brother did both!!

I think Jack had X beat up Brooke.

i think either could of!! but it doesnt matter - they both screwed up - even if the younger one didnt attack he still got his brother on her - its AS bad as attacking her- wanting to just being too much of a coward to do it .. 'ill know ill get my hard ass bro to do it'

i'm not sure if sam's friend meant that he did it or that he had his brother do it...i suppose it doesn't matter either way