i think with out cause i'm a Big ファン of niall and i just think that niall is just not getting a enough 歌う solo's i think that niall is better off with out and if あなた are wondering how this affects him well look at this pic
In my opinion, Niall is better off without. Now that's just in MY opinion, okay? He doesn't get to sing much solos and doesn't get enough attention, girls are all like "Omgee! Harreh!", "Louis, I 愛 you!", "Liam! Zayn! Marry me!" There aren't as much girls screaming for Niall. I know the ファン of 1D 愛 him a lot and people might disagree but as I said, it's just my opinion.
I wish both! :) Niall is an awesome singer when he is によって himself! Execpt, One direction wouldnt be the same without him! So I think he should sing with One DIrectio but also do some solo songs!!!!
i think he should be with one direction because they all look so cute together but he should get もっと見る solos AND もっと見る HUGS I MEAN WHO WOULDN'T WANT TO HUG HIM