Does anybody know if a マンガ is publishable if it is only finished in Pencil? (meaning if it's not Inked)

I'm asking because I am making a Manga/Comic syle Graphic Novel, but my inking skills aren't so good. Though I can draw in pencil and make it look great! (at least I'm happy with it:P) Also I'd like to use pencil to bypass most of the effects I'd otherwise use tonepaper for. I think it would turn out just fine in pencil(more like Fine Art over comic/manga style, I guess, hmmm), but I don't know if a publisher would accept it that way, so any clue?
 sesshyswind posted 1年以上前
next question »

マンガ 回答

PrinceKiseki said:
If あなた find a publisher who is not a complete traditionalist.
I agree about pencil, あなた can do really good shading without worrying about drips and smears.

Image has published things that use unusual mediums.
They have one where the line-art is done with a thick paint brush.

There is a artist who uses a black colored pencil to draw manga.

here is a site that talks about self publishing comics:
link

select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Thanks a million!!!... this is actually very incouraging :D... and for the link!
sesshyswind posted 1年以上前
SonOfPein said:
I bought a manga/comic that was drawn completely in pencil shading (or at least it looked to be in pencil shading because of how the pics were shaded and how soft the line marks were). It's called Miki Falls written/ drawn によって Mark Crilley and it was produced によって Harpercollins. So I am guessing the answer is yes since Crilley does it in his works. Perhaps it will say what he uses to draw with on his website somewhere?... Perhaps あなた can even ask him によって emailing him, cause I sent him a ファン letter and he actually responded!

markcrilley.com
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Thanks! That is really good to know, I'll look it up :D
sesshyswind posted 1年以上前
*
Your right I just checked it out and it does look like it was done in Pencil!! Perhaps with a light ink wash as a base to work with, または not even, but yah... Pencil! Thanks, this really helps me out! :D I'll send out an Eメール like あなた suggested just incase, though ;)
sesshyswind posted 1年以上前
*
Mark Crilley is who I ment in my answer. He uses a black prisma color pencil. He also makes tutotials on Youtube.
PrinceKiseki posted 1年以上前
*
Cool! So it really is pencil then. I thought it looked like pencil. Mark Crilley is an awesome artist and author, I 愛 his books!
SonOfPein posted 1年以上前
next question »