I like her but I do have to admit she is quite crazy.

I originally picked number 5 but thought I'd give her more credit for putting up with what she did for so long.

That is a great point. Putting up with Scott's treatment of her does deserve some respect, but she did try to kill a baby so still 5 for me.

Yeah, and the fact that it was HER baby doesn't really help, but I also give her credit for not going TOO overboard after having to deal with the news of being Jean's clone.

Trying to commit suicide and homicide at the same time isn't overboard? After attempted multiple baby murder?

It's not like she did like Jean and destroyed a galaxy because she was a little power hungry and then destroyed a Shi'ar ship and then destroyed herself after the X-men almost get killed for her a handful of time in the span of, what, 8 comics.

I thought she was just plain hungry. And compared to Jean anyone seems sane. Even Charles Manson.

Okay, I'll give you that point, and I guess using Wolverine as an example wouldn't be a good idea either, but I guess there are a LOT of insane people in the comics. Maddy just happens to be one of them.

Is there ever a sane person in comics? I mean usually they have some form of mental disorder or another

Umm...I think Valerie Cooper was pretty sane, but she wasn't a mutant. Hmm...a sane mutant. I'll have to think on that one.