Out of 1-10 I give it a 5.

5 as well from me.

I give it about a 6-7 because though they did not end it as the book had intended, they did try hard to put much of the story into as possible. A story that beautiful is almost impossible to duplicate onto screen. I would love to see them try to make an Inkspell and Inkdeath only because I am absolutely in love with the Trilogy.