ハーマイオニー・グレンジャー

この質問に回答する

ハーマイオニー・グレンジャー 質問

Young Hermoine Doing Underage Magic?

In the Philosophers Stone, before the sorting, Hermoine mentions that she has practised spells at home, even performing a few correctly. But the Ministry of Magic laws say a witch/wizard cannot use magic, legally, until they reach the age of seventeen.

Hermoine would have only been 11 years old...
Young Hermoine Doing Underage Magic?
 Mrs-Grint posted １年以上前
next question »

ハーマイオニー・グレンジャー 回答

Free_Spirit said:
technically the law states that once あなた start school...i think. But also because herione comes from a muggle family, and they probably wouln't have put too much of a strain on someone who doesn't know the rules. Whatconfuses me is at the start of HP 3 when harry does the lumos spell
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
*
But that was only in the movie, wasn't it? And since when do the 映画 pay attention to such details? ... :(
JAlanaE posted １年以上前
*
u can use magic on skol grounds while ur underage
duncylovescourt posted １年以上前
Hiding 3 comments... click to show.
*
i meant the Aunt thing
lhs1014 posted １年以上前
ToriG844 said:
Wizard kids permitted to do magic before they begin Hogwarts so when Hermione was practising spells it wasn't illegal because she hadn't actually started school.
 select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
felicity1111 said:
rememeber in the 2nd または 3rd movie she repares harrys glasses または was it fourth but that would be illegal wouldnt it? (but then in the 1st 移動する she was allowed to use magic)
select as best answer
posted １年以上前 
*
shes repiared them in the 1st movie
duncylovescourt posted １年以上前
*
when she repaired them in the philosopher's stone, they are on the hogwarts express. which technically could be considered 'in school'. BUT, in the chamber of secrets, she uses the oculus reparo spell again, but this time in diagon alley. not in school または on her way to school. = illegal underage use of magic 100%
ginny-weasley- posted １年以上前
*
It's later revealed that the Ministry can only learn where magic is used, not who used it. In magical family homes and places like Diagon Alley they rely on adult wizards and witches to prevent the kids from performing underage magic.
Flickerflame posted １年以上前
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!