ハリーポッター
What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)
ハリーポッター Which Director do あなた think has done the best job for the Harry Potter movies?
190 fans picked: |
Alfonso Cuaron (HP & The POA)
|
|||
David Yates (HP & The OOTP...Soon-HP & The HBP)
|
|||
Chris Columbus (HP & The SS. & .HP & The COS)
|
|||
Mike Newell (HP & The GOF)
|
|
Make your pick! | next poll >> |
-Kraamer
(kraamermich)
P.S. I think that Mike Newell should get 1st place, Alfonso Cuaron should get 2nd place, David Yates should get 3rd (the movie was still a good movie even though he made me mad) and Chris Columbus should get 4th because (although he kept to the story line) I thought the movie was boring, and not very exciting.
Thanks for reading this and providing me with your point of view and oppinon!
I thought that Columbus made the stories quite true to the books, but I think that they're rather boring, and besides none of the kids can act at all in the first two! Is that his fault? Not entirely, but I think that he probably could have gotten more out of them.
And as for Newell, well, I think that GoF was the worst movie. The story did not hold together at all (one of my friends who hasn't read the books went to see it and didn't understand anything that was going on :/ ) and he changed the characters way too much.
So, overall I would say that Cuaron was my favorite, but really I have been under-impressed with all of the adaptations.
I though David Yates did a horrible job. Alfonso in my opinion stayed most true to the book
couldnt agree with you more....except i thought Mike Newell did the best job
Yates sucks, the movies have so much cut out they don't make sense. He ditches plot and character development to make room for some more CGI clusterfucks (can anyone say attack on the burrow?)
Alfonso Cuaron was awesome, he made the best Harry Potter film and will always be the best HP director.
think David Yates was the worst i don't like him
ファンポップにサインインまたは登録してコメントを追加する