この質問に回答する

ハリーポッター 質問

A 質問 about Horcruxes

Does dark magic destroy Horcruxes? I know basilisk venom and fiendfyre destroyed them but Voldemort destroyed the horcrux within Harry just によって using the Avada Kedavra - would that have worked on all the horcruxes または was it only because it was Voldemort's own horcrux that he was able to destroy them in any way? (Sorry - I know this is a bit long-winded)
 saz19126 posted 1年以上前
next question »

ハリーポッター  ベストアンサー

Aimee147 said:
I don't think Dark Magic does work on all Horcruxes-remember that Harry was a living,breathing thing so he was able to die によって Avada Kedavra,whilst the other Horcruxes were inanimate objects and had no effect. (Remember how Harry,Ron and Hermione tried nearly every spell they knew and they were still untouched?) But something that totally goes against this is that Voldemort placed a charm on each horcrux to protect them from destruction,but then Harry was killed because Voldemort created the Horcrux within him unintentionally,so he did not offer him protection.So really,who knows? Maybe without protection and charms,Horcruxes may be able to be destroyed によって dark magic. (If that made any sense at all xD)
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Your explanation about protection 与えられた to the intended Horcruxes while the one created unintentionally (Harry) was not protected, is indeed a plausible explanation. Best answer !
LadyNottingham posted 1年以上前
*
Thank you! :D It just seemed the most logical explanation to me (:
Aimee147 posted 1年以上前
*
I voted the best answer :D
HARMONYforever posted 1年以上前
next question »

回答

dragonsmemory said:
To destroy a Horcrux, あなた can't just drop it off a tall building または attack it with a hammer. Horcruxes have to be wrecked beyond all magical repair. Few substances are that destructive.
If あなた recall, Neville killed Nagini によって beheading her. The sword, impregnated with basilisk venom, worked.
If the Dark magic in 質問 is extremely destructive, then yes, it could possibly work. However, as Crabbe found out, it is extremely difficult to control such destructive spells. If あなた are planning on hunting Horcruxes, I recommend あなた either use basilisk venom または the sword of Gryffindor.
As for Voldemort using the Killing Curse on the bit of soul in Harry, I can only say tghat both of them had wandeed into areas of magic untried and untested. They are a very unusualpair, to say the least. Dumbledore had to use a lot of guesswork in order to figure out the connection. Perhaps even Dumbledore cannot truly answer that.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
saraswathi612 said:
may be dark magic can destroy..but all of them those who used are with dark lord.probably they didn't have that much dare.
avada kedavra works on only living things so....
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
iggylukasiewicz said:
I don't think that dark magic can destory Horcruxes... unless it's very advanced, maybe. Horcruxes are very hard to destroy, so it's probably practically impossible.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
nimratanveer said:
why, arent u the observent one.......
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
next question »