この質問に回答する

ハリーポッター 質問

What parts were あなた disappointed to see removed from Deathly Hallows part 2?

I was super disappointed that they toke out the scene where フレッド dies. I as looking フォワード, 前進, 楽しみにして to crying ymeyes out there. I also missed the part where Percy and the rest of the Weasleys make up. That was one of my favourite parts in the book.
*
agree! I missed the percy scene too!
halpertfan11 posted 1年以上前
 JamieBrooks95 posted 1年以上前
next question »

ハリーポッター 回答

MrsEmmaPeel said:
I'm not disappointed about the movie at all. I really enjoyed how it turned out, but I still kind of wish they added the mudblood and the friendship break up scene between Lily and Snape in "The Prince Tale's" Those who never read the book might wouldn't fully understand that much of their relationship together without those small bits.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
I totally agree with that.
Vixie79 posted 1年以上前
*
Agreed. And I wished for the epilogue to be longer, I wanted to see Scorpius' face *pout*
TheHPMerlinFan posted 1年以上前
*
I know! My Mom thought that Snape was Harry's real father!
PotterLambert93 posted 1年以上前
Ash24 said:
The movie wasnt disappointing in my eyes, ive watched it twice, i would have liked to see Fred's death because it kind of jumped from him alive then dead if あなた know what i mean, the house elves would have been awesome to see, especially Kreacher, having Harry not break the elder wand till he mended his original wand would have been good, but all in all i think they made another great Harry Potter movie
select as best answer
 The movie wasnt disappointing in my eyes, ive watched it twice, i would have liked to see Fred's death because it kind of jumped from him alive then dead if あなた know what i mean, the house elves would have been awesome to see, especially Kreacher, having Harry not break the elder wand till he mended his original wand would have been good, but all in all i think they made another great Harry Potter movie
posted 1年以上前 
*
I agree with you.
D_J267 posted 1年以上前
Lil-mIA said:
The person who plays James II
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
He was in there he just didn't say anything :P
JamieBrooks95 posted 1年以上前
LadyNottingham said:
In Severus' memories : "And my soul, Dumbledore ? Mine ?"

It could have been easy to insert that sentence, just after Dumbledore had talked Severus into killing him.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
That phrase too !
RealSunshine posted 1年以上前
*
Absolutely!
jameswilson posted 1年以上前
*
And I forgot another scene I really missed in the movie : when Harry vindicates Severus in front of everybody. So that everyone knows how true Severus was. And I'm sure that Voldemort's face, learning the truth, would have been priceless !
LadyNottingham posted 1年以上前
Lackson4ever85 said:
Nothing,i think this movie was so perfect:D
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
RealSunshine said:
I was looking フォワード, 前進, 楽しみにして to the history of the Childhood of Albus Dumbledore. In the book it is so intense, and Harry`s interest for it, is in maximum. And because of the big range of emotions this story has, I really wanted to see it.
I wanted to watch もっと見る about Fred`s death, not watching Bellatrix explode. I wanted to see her laughing, as in the book.
I wanted to watch Tedy Lupin in Hogwarts Express.
I wanted to see Harry repair his wand with the Elder Wand, then he could break it, but this didn`t happen.
And also the line of Severus: And my soul Dumbledore?
In the end, I really wanted the last phrase 'All was well' to be mentioned, really really bad. It would comfort the viewer...

Everything else was just EPIC :D
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Agree with everything!
jameswilson posted 1年以上前
*
Thank あなた ^^
RealSunshine posted 1年以上前
PotterLambert93 said:
I really loved the movie, but there was so much details that were left out! Severus and Lilly as teenagers, death of Fred, Percy reuniting with his family and the 19 years later was short. I also noticed that the clip from the previews where Voldemort grabs Harry's face and asks him "why do あなた live?" was also missing!!!!
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
rachelanna525 said:
I wasn't dissapointed to see フレッド die because i read the 本 and knew he was, just as i knew Lupin and ニンファドーラ・トンクス was.But, i still was crying. The part i found VERY dissapointing was how Teddy Lupin wasn't even SEEN at ALL!!!! WTF, man, WTF... That made me really sad. But, over all that, it was EPIC!!!!! <3 (ron weasley 4ever!)
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Agreed, if あなた didn't read the book, you're left with no idea how he died. Hell, we still don't know the exact details even if あなた read, all we saw was some female Death Eater near him.
FawkesTears posted 1年以上前
Mugwaii said:
I missed the part from the end of the book where Hermione tells her kid to "give Neville our love" and the kid says "Mum - あなた can't give 愛 to a professor..."
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Aw yea! Too bad ...
jameswilson posted 1年以上前
Fairy8346 said:
pettigrew's death and TEDDY LUPIN!!!!

select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
lovedrchase said:
Arianna's story....it's was one of my favourite parts of the book
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
halpertfan11 said:
1) Better R/H kiss- didn't mind too much that it wasnt in the right place, but あなた could barely see their faces
2) Better フレッド death scene- Fred's death was not nearly as sad and significant as it should have been
3)Some mention of the Harry's invisibility マント, 隠す being the third hallow?- not 100% sure, but pretty positive this was never mentioned
4)Teddy Lupin- it was so sweet that Harry is Teddy's godfather, I mean seriously the pregnancy and the child were not talked about once
5) Better epilogue scene- I think the film crew did an amazing job of making Dan, Rupert, and Emma look older but none of the comedic lines from the book were used between the parents and the kids. Also, full names of all the kids werent mentioned.

-I'm really not a complainer as far as HP 映画 are concerned. I really liked DH 2, I just think that if another 10 分 were added to this film we would have been able to include もっと見る details and would have been an all around better, もっと見る satisfying potter finale.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Agreed about the invisibility マント, 隠す thing - they never mentioned it at all. Also about number four!!!
jameswilson posted 1年以上前
zanhar1 said:
All of the Bellatrix parts!
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
ChocoLuvr101 said:
1. Some parts of the Prince's Tale. If I were watching this from the POV of someone who hasn't read DH, I wouldn't really understand the Snape/Lily thing.
2. I can't believe they cut out Percy making up with his family.
3. Most of the dialogue from the epilogue. Like when they were talking about Ron's driving test.
4. Fred's death.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Agreed about the Prince's Tale - I've heard several accounts of people who haven't read the 本 thinking that scene in the movie meant Snape was Harry's father. Ridiculous!
jameswilson posted 1年以上前
jameswilson said:
I don't want to get ranting, but here are the main things I really would have liked to see in the movie.

1. The King's クロス scene: I know this scene was included in the movie - but it was so short and SO many things were left out. However, this is mostly due to the fact that the filmmakers have been leaving the things that led up to this part out. A) How about Dumbledore explaining to Harry everything that happened with him, Grindlewald, Aberforth, Ariana, etc. Oh yea - they completely abandoned the Ariana story and barely mentioned Grindlewald (and only in the first film). B) At this point Harry is supposed to be PISSED at Dumbledore - Dumbledore even cries in the book because he feels so terrible about what Harry had to go through.
This was such a touching and emotional part in the book - instead they just made it a quick scene where Dumbledore says some clever lines, including everyone's お気に入り from the book - the one about things being real and inside our heads.

2. Harry and Voldemort's Final Battle: What the fuck? I'm sorry for my language, but honestly? They could have made this amazing - I figured they would at least draw out the battle because filmmakers 愛 action. In the book they duel in front of everyone in the great hall - it is an incredibly dramatic scene in which Harry informs Voldemort about everything he's done wrong - including about the fact that Snape was on their side the whole time. Where was all this? How could they leave this out?! And then of course the crap with Voldemort and Bellatrix turning into ashes? What? This scene could have been truly amazing and they threw it away.

3. The Very End: How about Harry repairs his wand with the Elder wand and then returns it to Dumbledore's grave instead of snapping it in half?

There were a plethora of other things I was severely disappointed in as well, including the pensive scene, and the many other missing aspects of the battle such as Percy turning up and all. Additionally, what happened to the scene with Ollivander at shell cottage? I guess Harry doesn't care about fixing his wand, the weird incident that happened on the night of the seven Potters, または about Grindlewald and Gregorovitch anymore.

I'm sorry I ended up ranting. It's just incredible disappointment from a very dedicated ファン :[


select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
next question »