|
Amy3422 said:
Well, I know a lot of people (including me) who like both of them, but I think that a lot of people come at Ginny from a movie perspective. Bonnie Wright was cast before Ginny's character was fully developped in the books, so she isn't perfectly suited to the role. In the movies, Ginny's personality is pretty much cut, so she comes off looking like a pretty forced and not very interesting plot device. Most of her and Harry's relationship is cut, as are most of Ginny's funniest lines from the book. There is also the fact that Harry keeps her so separate from the rest of his life, and Ginny is not the most important thing in his thoughts. Personally, I find this believable and think that it shows a lot about Harry's character. (He's afraid of her being killed, remember.) However, I expect that some people are looking for a 'Twilight'-type romance and don't find them to be a passionate enough couple. As for Cho, we see her through Harry's perspective, which is hugely biased. (He doesn't handle the relationship very well, but it's easy to blame Cho if あなた don't think about her side of the story.) A lot of the humour in the fifth book comes from the fact that they are so incompatible as people. To me, they were never meant to be a real romance; just something that adds layers to the story. I guess the 映画 played their relationship もっと見る seriously, which made it less entertaining than in the books. Lastly, I'll just add that people 愛 to hate, and that there's always someone who the ファン (or anti-fans) gang up on. There usually isn't a very good reason for it, other than that the character conflicts with someone's idea of what they want to see happen.
|
|