ハリーポッターｖｓトワイライト Article: Things Twilight and HP both have...

4

posted by ariba_c

Not sure what to タイトル this exactly:P

Anyways this was a コメント on some フォーラ here I cant remember and I liked it so decided to post it as an article. It was によって Lumos_Maxima I believe.

あなた have Robert Pattison play Edward - we had him play Cedric. He even admitted to enjoying play Cedric もっと見る than Edward ;)

あなた have Jacob and Edward - we have Draco Malfoy and Blaise Zabini.

あなた have Bella 白鳥, スワン - we have Bellatrix Lestrange who could Avada Kedavra your Bella any day.

あなた have Jacob Black - we have Remus Lupin who is the real werewolf here. Jacob isn't even a werewolf, he's a shape shifter.

あなた have Jacob Black - We have Sirius Black who can turn into an awesome black dog. And no, we didn't copy Jacob in any way because 6 of the Harry Potter 本 were written BEFORE the first twilight book as published so unless JKR could time travel to the future, I highly doubt that she copied Stephanie.

あなた have the Volturi - we have death eaters who could kill the volturi in a 秒 using Avada Kedavra.

あなた have Aro - We have Voldemort.

あなた have bella's scar from a vampire bite - We have Harry Potter's famous scar on his forehead in shape of a lightning bolt.

あなた have a fight scene that never happened - We have the battle of Hogwarts.

あなた have Alice - We have Professor Trelawney.

あなた have rare vampire powers - We have magical wizards and witches.

あなた have a girl who jumped off a bridge when her boyfriend left her - we have a girl who stayed to find and destroy horcruxes and fight in the war when the person she loved left them.

あなた have Rosalie - we have Fleur

あなた have the Cullens - we have the Weasleys. I would rather be a Weasley any day.

あなた have Esme - We have Molly Weasley who loved Harry like her own son.

あなた have like 3 pedophiles (edward, jacob, quil) - we have 3 メリダとおそろしの森 Gryffindors who helped save the wizard world.

Bella would rather die and be with Edward and have her parents go through depression than be a human - Hermione would rather erase any memories of her existence from her parent's mind and have them 移動する to Australia than watch them go through harm because of the war.

Bella jumped off a cliff to hear Edward's voice when he left her - Ginny ストール, 盗んだ the sword of Godric Gryffindor, restarted Dumbledore's Army with her フレンズ and fought in the battle of Hogwarts when Harry left to protect her.

Manonx, Kadaj and 2 others like this

10 more comments

loading additional comments...

ariba_c @mr-cullen Why cant someone compare alice with trelawney? and Why is this a stupid article? @miss_attitude Well than yes Bella was brave at times I guess. @cassie Okay so even if they did know what the spells will do what will they do about it? And they think of the spells so fast that I really doubt they will have time to register what is about to happen. Most of them can only run and not much else. Jane

cassie-1-2-3 Well nothing. The Volturi wouldn't even be able to read their minds, unless Aro has Edward with him, and is constantly touching him. Even then, someone would have to vocalize to everyone else what is about to happen, before anything is said. But even if they somehow don't manage to get to the wizard before the spell is even cast, they can dodge the beam. Whether the spell will do any damage or not depends on the actual spell. Anything that requires direct contact with the beam would be a poor choice.

cassie-1-2-3 Unless Renata's there. She can put up a physical shield that would probably block anything, up until the right opportunity arises.

ariba_c ^Thats true! Anyways its not like there will ever be a wizards vs. vampire fight so now one can really say who would win. They both have good chances honestly!

MISS_ATTITUDE2 Right.........

Manonx This article: lol ^^

mr-cullen Trelawney is a show off alice can "see" the future not predict

ariba_c Alice can see the future and is usually accurate about it but it can change based upon decisions people make. Like she thought Bella was dead but it turns out she wasnt... It was Trelawney herself who made the prophecy concerning Voldemort and the one with the power to vanquish him (Voldemort took this to mean Harry Potter) during her job interview with Albus Dumbledore. At the end of the 1993–1994 school year, she accurately predicted the escape of Peter Pettigrew and return of Lord Voldemort. Yes she is a show off but I like her character! It makes her funny and interesting:)

PromptDreamer I agree with you, ariba_c! She may be a show-off and annoying but at least she wasn't really a fraud (I mean like, she made two accurate prophecies!). ~PromptDreamer

ariba_c haha ya!

graystone Wow, it's amazing! Good work, ariba_c. :)

mr-cullen Oh good.alice thought bella was ded because of jacob. and what abt Trelawney she always said things about harry's death.. was that happened? @PromptDreamer 2 prophecies!!!how marvelous work of Trelawney isn't it??

mr-cullen you mean to say Trelawney is better than alice??

emilykuru Bella would rather die and be with Edward and have her parents go through depression than be a human - Hermione would rather erase any memories of her existence from her parent's mind and have them move to Australia than watch them go through harm because of the war. Go Hermione! Team Potter! I agree on all accounts with the article except that Alice is a much better seer than Trelawney.

ariba_c I never said trelawney is better than alice. Just putting that out there. I like both honestly. Im not a huge fan of alice and neither am I of trelawney. EDWARD thought Bella was dead b/c of Jacob. NOT Alice. She was never serious about Harry's deaths, yes. They both made mistakes! I never said either one was perfect:)

ariba_c @emilykuru: Thanks:)

mr-cullen i said alice cuz she didn't saw bella coming out of water after all she told them isn't it?? Alice came at chrlie to meet him found bella alive *sorry for my grammar*

ariba_c I am so confused! You said Alice thought bella was dead b/c of Jacob. Youd never said anything about her coming out of the water!

Sallymagi "You have like 3 pedophiles (edward, jacob, quil) - we have 3 brave Gryffindors who helped save the wizard world." - HP has pedophiles too. Lupin, who married Tonks (13 years difference) for instance. Besides, I don't think I'll call those Twilight guys for "pedophiles". I mean, Edward is kinda "stuck in life," so he doesn't grow, meaning he is still the same age (kinda). Well, Quill and Jacob arent' supposed to grow either, when their "soulmates" (or whatever, don't remember what it's called) aren't the same age.. right? Not sure, it's been a long time since I've read anything with Twilight. Btw, I still support HP

cunha27 ^I really wished people actually found out the meaning of words before using them. Please look up what paedophilia means, specially if you're going to use it as point in an argument. You'll find that out of the two series Harry Potter was the one that had what most resembled paedophilia in it and it wasn't Lupin.

Sallymagi ^I know what a pedophile is. When Tonks was 11, Lupin was 24 When Tonks was 17, lupin was 30

cunha27 Yes, but did he even know her when she was that old? He was never interested in Tonks when she was 11 or 17. Their relationship started when Tonks was 24, when she was well and truly a consenting adult.

Sallymagi ^True :) I suppose the other paedophile in Harry Potter is Greyback. That's obvious.

cunha27 Yeah, but besides him, there's also Victor Krum who at 18 years of age snogged a 14 year old Hermione. Definitely doggy and very much within the defenition of paedophilia.

Sallymagi Yeah, I guess so. Didn't really think about him. But when I think about it, it was kinda creepy, cause he sat starring at her in the library for months before talking to her.