この質問に回答する

ハリーポッターvsトワイライト 質問

where are the graphic and explicit sex scenes in Breaking Dawn?

I've seen people on this spot criticize Twilight because of all the "explicit" and "detailed" sex scenes.


To 一覧 a couple


"What are あなた talking about? The fourth book is REALLY graphic! With the sex scenes and when Bella is giving birth... it was actually kinda disturbing"

"Yes, and detailed, DETAILED, disturbing キス scenes. And ripping clothes off? Descirbing how perfect Edward is without his clothes? Yeah, if that's not somehow porn, what is it? :) OWNED!"


I'm trying to take these claims seriously, but I haven't seen any evidence of this.
Can someone quote these detailed erotic scenes? I can't find them.

Here's all of Breaking Dawn
link
 youknowit101 posted 1年以上前
next question »

ハリーポッターvsトワイライト  ベストアンサー

KateKicksAss said:
I didn't think it was that explicit.

To be honest, I actually thought Stephenie Meyer did a pretty good job with the sex scenes. Basically saying enough so あなた know what's going on, but not being so graphic that it's disturbing または gross.
A lot better than in some of the 本 I've read, *shudders*.
I mean, that's another thing that it's really stupid to criticize Twilight over, I mean, she made what could have been R-Rated scenes into basically PG-ish ones.
As for the birth scene, it was bloody, but that also didn't go into excessive gory details. It was a little graphic, but it really wasn't too unpleasant, I mean, I don't see how she could have done a better job making it not excessively disgusting または anything, so I too don't really see what people are complaining about.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Well said!
Persephone16 posted 1年以上前
*
あなた think graphic is gross? :(
boolander25 posted 1年以上前
*
graphic IS gross
Mountain_Troll posted 1年以上前
next question »

回答

boolander25 said:
Yeah... there really aren't any. The book is not graphic, at all. It's like hardcore fluff at the most. Your 秒 quote made me laugh. That person has obviously never seen porn, lol.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Hardcore fluff? lol
HecateA posted 1年以上前
Kiniko90 said:
There are sex scenes in Breaking Dawn? What? No, as far as I know, there are no graphic sex scenes in BD. The entire thing is just hinted at with Edward talking about bitten pillows and some bruising on Bella's body (chapter 5). The only graphic scene in the book is when Bella gives birth to Renesmee (Chapter 18). In fact one of my problems with BD was the lack of sex scenes where instead Smeyer gave us some crazy gratuitous gruesome birthing scene that could easily scar anyone for life.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
AllyAM said:
Sex Scenes: They're not that graphic, but I can see how people wouldn't like what's being implied.

Now the birthing scene is a totally different story for me. I was disturbed によって the descriptions of how they were going to have to tear her open to get the baby out. Not to mention I was a little scarred によって the "MY BABY IS DROWNING!!!" passage.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
rofl
luv_warriorcatz posted 1年以上前
Angel-Trix said:
There aren't any actual sex scenes but haven't あなた read New Moon where Bella was locked in Edward's room and Edward comes back early? If I remember, they were locked in a deep passionate キッス and Edward brought Bella's カーフ, ふくらはぎ around his hip (yes, it is actually written that that happened).

Read chapter 8 of Eclipse (pages 185 and onwards to be exact), and tell me if isn't erotic.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
KatiiCullen94 said:
IM SOO HAPPY THAT BREAKING DAWN IS GOING TO BE EXPLICIT!!

the way it should be . the 12-13 are going to just have to suck it up. they will be doing it one 日 あなた know. Sex is sex, never will change
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
next question »