この質問に回答する

ハリーポッターvsトワイライト 質問

Bella vs. Harry

1.) Who has had a harder life
2.) Who has もっと見る supporting friends.
3.) Who has a tougher choice to make: Jacob または Edward, Hallows または Horcruxes.
4.) Who has better parentel figures: Carlisle, Charlie, Billy, etc. または Dumbledore, Molly, Sirius, etc.
5.) Who is a better person? [nicer and もっと見る supportive of friends, respectful to teachers, etc.]
6.) Who has had to deal with a tougher bully - Lauren and Rosalie または Pansy, Draco[eep!:)], Crabbe, Goyle, + half the Slytherins, Ministry, and Umbridge.]
7.) Who has made a bigger sacrifice: Bella - she gave up her life to be a vampire just so she can be with the one she loved または Harry - he, although he was scared to his bone, gave himself up to Voldemort so everyone that was fighting would be protected and LV wouldn't be able to hurt them.

Please try to explain your answers. I'm really curious because people usually compare Edward and Harry cause they are both the main guys in the series, but Bella and Harry are the main characters.
 DracoLuver posted 1年以上前
next question »

ハリーポッターvsトワイライト 回答

Gred_and_Forge said:
1.) Who has had a harder life
-Harry Potter, no doubt. He never knew his parents; he grew up with the Dursleys; Voldemort tried to kill him numerous times, the first time being when he was just a baby; etc.

2.) Who has もっと見る supporting friends
-Harry. Who's Bella's friends? Jacob? Angela? They do not compare to Ron and Hermione who have been with him through everything, no matter how dangerous the situation is.

3.) Who has a tougher choice to make: Jacob または Edward, Hallows または Horcruxes.
-Hmm, sparkly boy? または 狼, オオカミ like boy? So hard. Everyone knew she was going to pick Edward (obviously). Harry has a race with Voldemort to see who gets their items first because it could mean life または death.

4.) Who has better parentel figures: Carlisle, Charlie, Billy, etc. または Dumbledore, Molly, Sirius, etc.
-Molly and Sirius are way better parental figures to Harry. Molly treated him like a son. Charlie didn't even know that Edward was sneaking in Bella's room every night, and he's a police chief?

5.) Who is a better person? [nicer and もっと見る supportive of friends, respectful to teachers, etc.]
-Bella is not nicer または supportive to anyone who isn't Edward. Harry has disagreements with some teachers only because he was treated unfairly, but in the end, Harry respected them enough to name his child after them (Albus Severus)

6.) Who has had to deal with a tougher bully - Lauren and Rosalie または Pansy, Draco[eep!:)], Crabbe, Goyle, + half the Slytherins, Ministry, and Umbridge.]
-Lauren and Rosalie are poor excuses for bullies. Eventually Rosalie moved on, but she didn't make Bella's life hell. Draco and the Slytherins always picked on Harry. Don't even get me started on Umbridge, that biznatch.

7.) Who has made a bigger sacrifice: Bella - she gave up her life to be a vampire just so she can be with the one she loved または Harry - he, although he was scared to his bone, gave himself up to Voldemort so everyone that was fighting would be protected and LV wouldn't be able to hurt them.
-Harry gave up way もっと見る than Bella. He gave up his フレンズ and girlfriend to 検索 for the horcruxes so he could save the world! Bella just wanted to save Edward. No 質問 that Harry made a bigger sacrifice.
select as best answer
 1.) Who has had a harder life -Harry Potter, no doubt. He never knew his parents; he grew up with the Dursleys; Voldemort tried to kill him numerous times, the first time being when he was just a baby; etc. 2.) Who has もっと見る supporting フレンズ -Harry. Who's Bella's friends? Jacob? Angela? They do not compare to Ron and Hermione who have been with him through everything, no matter how dangerous the situation is. 3.) Who has a tougher choice to make: Jacob または Edward, Hallows または Horcruxes. -Hmm, sparkly boy? または 狼, オオカミ like boy? So hard. Everyone knew she was going to pick Edward (obviously). Harry has a race with Voldemort to see who gets their items first because it could mean life または death. 4.) Who has better parentel figures: Carlisle, Charlie, Billy, etc. または Dumbledore, Molly, Sirius, etc. -Molly and Sirius are way better parental figures to Harry. Molly treated him like a son. Charlie didn't even know that Edward was sneaking in Bella's room every night, and he's a police chief? 5.) Who is a better person? [nicer and もっと見る supportive of friends, respectful to teachers, etc.] -Bella is not nicer または supportive to anyone who isn't Edward. Harry has disagreements with some teachers only because he was treated unfairly, but in the end, Harry respected them enough to name his child after them (Albus Severus) 6.) Who has had to deal with a tougher bully - Lauren and Rosalie または Pansy, Draco[eep!:)], Crabbe, Goyle, + half the Slytherins, Ministry, and Umbridge.] -Lauren and Rosalie are poor excuses for bullies. Eventually Rosalie moved on, but she didn't make Bella's life hell. Draco and the Slytherins always picked on Harry. Don't even get me started on Umbridge, that biznatch. 7.) Who has made a bigger sacrifice: Bella - she gave up her life to be a vampire just so she can be with the one she loved または Harry - he, although he was scared to his bone, gave himself up to Voldemort so everyone that was fighting would be protected and LV wouldn't be able to hurt them. -Harry gave up way もっと見る than Bella. He gave up his フレンズ and girlfriend to 検索 for the horcruxes so he could save the world! Bella just wanted to save Edward. No 質問 that Harry made a bigger sacrifice.
posted 1年以上前 
bri-marie said:
1) Harry. He ロスト his parents and was forced to live with a 'family' that never cared for him. He was forced to defeat Voldemort, and ロスト many loved ones along the way (Sirius, Dumbledore, Lupin, Fred, Dobby, Hedwig, Tonks).
2) Harry. Bella doesn't really have friends. She has a big family, though.
3) Harry. He had no idea where the Horcruxes または Hallows were. Also, the Horcruxes were almost impossible to destroy, but they were the only obvious way to kill Voldemort. The Hallows were almost impossible to find, but it wasn't a sure-fire way to bring him down.
4) Bella. I really don't think Sirius または Dumbledore were great parental figures at all. Molly was, but she was trumped によって Sirius and Dumbledore so . . .
5)Harry. Bella complained about how nice people were on her first day, and she ditched her フレンズ as soon as Edward came into her life.
6) Harry. あなた forgot to mention Severus. On that basis alone Harry wins. I 愛 Severus to death, but he is not a man あなた want to cross.
7) Harry. Do I really have to explain why? I think that chapter in DH when he's walking through the woods explains it.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
ThePrincesTale said:
1.) Who has had a harder life
-Harry, definitely. He has always lived under the shadow of Voldemort, he knows his life must either include, または end in, murder, and even before he knew this he was abused によって the Dursleys.
2.) Who has もっと見る supporting friends.
Bella doesn't have many friends. Her boyfriend takes up her whole life. And Ron and Hermione both have flaws, but are brilliant friends. They risked their lives to save Harry's on numerous occasions.
3.) Who has a tougher choice to make: Jacob または Edward, Hallows または Horcruxes.
Harry. The whole world rests on his right decisions, as he is the only one that can vanquish Voldemort for good.
4.) Who has better parentel figures: Carlisle, Charlie, Billy, etc. または Dumbledore, Molly, Sirius, etc.
Hmmmm...hard one. The thing is, I actually like Charlie. He's gruff and blunt in a nice sort of way, and defined cares about Bella. Harry certainly wouldn't be alive without Dumbledore, but Sirius...he's not a great role model. He's reckless etc. So don't know on this one.
5.) Who is a better person? [nicer and もっと見る supportive of friends, respectful to teachers, etc.]
Harry (duh).He was ready TO DIE for his friends. And for so many other reasons it's not even funny. I see Bella as a little....I don't know..selfish, maybe???
6.) Who has had to deal with a tougher bully - Lauren and Rosalie または Pansy, Draco[eep!:)], Crabbe, Goyle, + half the Slytherins, Ministry, and Umbridge.]
あなた forgot Voldemort. I would consider him a bully. And at one stage Harry had most of the wizarding world against him. Harry's bullies were just evil while Bella..not so much.
7.) Who has made a bigger sacrifice: Bella - she gave up her life to be a vampire just so she can be with the one she loved または Harry - he, although he was scared to his bone, gave himself up to Voldemort so everyone that was fighting would be protected and LV wouldn't be able to hurt them.
*snort* Bella made sacrifices?? She wanted to become a vampire in the first place. Whereas Harry, as stated before, meant to give up his life so as to save his friends. HE WALKED RIGHT TO VOLDEMORT DEFENCELESS, ON PURPOSE. Sorry for the caps, but some people don't get it. Plus, half his life was devoted to fighting him.

Harry wins
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
bessmarvin1 said:
1.) Who has had a harder life

Of course,Harry

2.) Who has もっと見る supporting friends.

Ron and Hermione.They are way better than the so called "friends"in Twilight

3.) Who has a tougher choice to make: Jacob または Edward, Hallows または Horcruxes.

Harry.Cause Hallows and Horcruxes are important than boys.

4.) Who has better parentel figures: Carlisle, Charlie, Billy, etc. または Dumbledore, Molly, Sirius, etc.
Harry

5.) Who is a better person? [nicer and もっと見る supportive of friends, respectful to teachers, etc.] Harry

6.) Who has had to deal with a tougher bully - Lauren and Rosalie または Pansy, Draco[eep!:)], Crabbe, Goyle, + half the Slytherins, Ministry, and Umbridge.] Harry
7.) Who has made a bigger sacrifice: Bella - she gave up her life to be a vampire just so she can be with the one she loved または Harry - he, although he was scared to his bone, gave himself up to Voldemort so everyone that was fighting would be protected and LV wouldn't be able to hurt them.

COME ON...that is a stupid question.Of course Harry.Becoming a vampire is hardly a sacrifice.Actually,it is really stupid


select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
LoopyLuna96 said:
1. Harry. His parents died, and he had to spend a whole 年 (or there abouts) on a quest where there was risk everyday that he could be killed, whilst trying to find things that could literally be anything.
2. Harry. Although Bella did have friedns that supported her, Harry's were better. Even at eleven, they wouldn't let him risk his life alone.
3. Harry. His choice decided the fate of the world. Bella's choice was between two guys, and it only affected her life.
4. Harry. There were some good parental figures in Twilight, but Molly is just the best parental figure ever. And Sirius really cared. Dumbledore did, too.
5. Harry. We never really see Bella interact with teachers, so I can't コメント on that, but Harry is respectful to all of his teachers, even Snape, excluding a minor slip-of-the-tongue in HP.
6. Harry, obviously. His bullies were actually using racial slurs about his mother and friends, and essentially made his life a living hell sometimes. Bella's 'bullies' never really say anything to her, it's just obvious they don't really like her.
7. Harry was willing to die to save people he didn't even know. To be fair, Bella was never really put in that situation, but going from the books, Bella sacrifice was selfish and I don't rate it at all.

:D
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
foopetsrule said:
1) Harry
2) Harry
3) Harry
4) Harry
5) Harry
6) Harry
7) Harry

duh
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
niamhxxx said:
1)Harry- His parents are dead and a lot of people he really cares about die または get hurt for him.

2)Harry- Hermione and Ron are so supportive and left their families and lives behind for Harry even though he didn't want them to.

3)Harry- The world doesn't depend on who Bella spends her life with. :/

4)Bella- Harry doesn't ave the best parental figures with Dumbeldore and Sirius.

5)Harry- He would do anything for his friends, he gave himself up to voldemort, and he knew he would もっと見る than likely face death, so they wouldn't get hurt. Bella ditched hers after Edward came. :/

6)Harry- So many people put him down. Draco and most of Slytherin are at him all the time and Umbridge was at him all through da 5th book. Rosalie または Lauren barely do anything to Bella, like their not even in the book enough to anyway.

7)Harry- Bella would sorta still be alive after becoming a vampire but with Harry he would just go BANG!! and hes gone.


select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
cupcakeimissyou said:
1.) Who has had a harder life

Harry of course.


2.) Who has もっと見る supporting friends.

Harry

3.) Who has a tougher choice to make: Jacob または Edward, Hallows または Horcruxes.

Harry!

4.) Who has better parentel figures: Carlisle, Charlie, Billy, etc. または Dumbledore, Molly, Sirius, etc.

I think Harry because. who wouldnt want dumblodore to be a father like figure to them he's strong and the most powerful wizard around i mean everyone was really a parent figure to harry well just about every good adult around!


5.) Who is a better person? [nicer and もっと見る supportive of friends, respectful to teachers, etc.]

Harry

6.) Who has had to deal with a tougher bully - Lauren and Rosalie または Pansy, Draco[eep!:)], Crabbe, Goyle, + half the Slytherins, Ministry, and Umbridge.]

Harrrryyy


7.) Who has made a bigger sacrifice: Bella - she gave up her life to be a vampire just so she can be with the one she loved または Harry - he, although he was scared to his bone, gave himself up to Voldemort so everyone that was fighting would be protected and LV wouldn't be able to hurt them.

HARRRYY
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
sy-sy said:
def. harry his parents died forced to live with the dursleys and bella can see her parents at all times and harrys life is threatened at all times becuz of voldy
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
next question »