In all honesty, I think Yoona's a good singer but on the bottom 3 while I think Tiffany's a good singer but she's 5th in my rank. For me, she's not that consistent of sustaining her voice. She "broke" it off twice (i think?). I don't need to explain the dancing part cause obviously Yoona's better hands down...

For me Yoona is 8th/9th in singing and 3rd/4th in dancing
Tiffany is 5th in singing and 9th in dancing.

so overall, Yoona is a bit better.

HaHaHa!!!!
Of Course Tiffany!!!!!

For me, Tiffany is 5th best singer and 9th best dancer. That adds up too 14.
Yoona is 7th best singer and 3rd best dancer. That adds up too 10.

FYI, you want the lowest score.

I admit, Tiffany is more talented in singing than Yoona but Yoona is the best dancer than her .. and Yoona is my bias that's why i picked her :P

Yoona
Singing 8th
Dancing 3rd/4th

Tiffany
Singing 4th/5th
Dancing 9th

For me, Tiffany is 5th best singer and 9th best dancer.
Yoona is 8th best singer and 3rd best dancer. so it is a little better Yoona

Ehh I don't know ~~~ fany cuz she's good at singing and not that bad at dancing =_+

She's better at singing.
For most of the polls, not many people pick her.

I picked Yoona because she's a better dancer than Tiffany is at singing imo

Yoona: 8+3=11/2=5.5
Tiffany: 5+9=14/2=7

Did I do something wrong?

It's more fair if you actually give them grades.
Singing: Tiffany 7/10, Yoona 3/10
Dancing: Tiffany 5/10, Yoona 8/10

Tiffany: 12/20, Yoona 11/20.

:>

fany

Yoona

I gotta say, Yoona.
Yoona's Rank in dancing: 3rd, Along with Sooyoung
Tiffany's Rank in dancing: 9th

Yoona's Rank in singing: 9th
Tiffany's Rank in singing: 4th

So I gotta say, Its Yoona. Probably both if Sooyoung had beaten Yoona in dancing. P.S. Yoona and Tiffany is not in my first 5 biases.