Where Season 4 Of “Game Of Thrones” Went Wrong 

This BuzzFeed homepage is tailored for our readers in the USA. Make it your default. This BuzzFeed homepage is tailored for our readers in the USA. Switch to US Have you seen BuzzFeed English? Come check it out!  

23 Signs You're The Chandler Of Your Friend Group

31 Problems Every Professional Chef Will Understand

27 Struggles Only British People Will Understand

What Your British University Says About You

What Did These Celebs Do Before They Were Famous?

What Everyday Foods Do You Find Utterly Revolting?

68 Thoughts Every Traveler Has On Their Trip Around The World

17 Interesting Things You Didn't Know About Apple

Lululemon Stock Plunges Below Price Of Single Sports Bra On Grim Earnings

A Startup Looks To Build On Facebook's Latest Billion-Dollar Business

22 Facts That Will Change The Way You Look At Giraffes

14 Inspiring Pets Who Don't Let Anything Get Them Down

Kelly Rowland Is Pregnant And Announced It In The Sweetest Way Possible

Kanye West's Bonnaroo Set Was Great Even Though He's Still Mad At Pearl Jam

The Definitive Ranking Of All Of Nicki Minaj's Music Videos

How The Worst Political State In The Country Ruined The Republican Party's Best Hope

President Obama Discovers His Daughter Was Violating Tumblr's Terms Of Service

Immigration Revolt: House Majority Leader Eric Cantor Loses Republican Primary

Eric Cantor's Election Loss As Explained By "Toy Story"

7 Car Hacks That Will Change Your Life

Ubisoft Is Excluding Women From The New "Assassin's Creed" And People Are Furious

New York Times Crossword Puzzlers Revolt Over New App

19 Secrets For Shopping At Publix That Will Blow Your Mind

20 Incredible Things You Never Knew About Amazon.com

For Everyone Whose Life Has Changed Since Chris Pratt Became A Human God

Bill Murray Ended Up In This Couple's Engagement Photos For Some Reason

Mariah Carey Tries Pawning Off Photo Of Herself From 1997, Forgets The Internet Exists

Mila Kunis Gives A PSA On Men Saying "We're Pregnant"

Behind Crazy Eyes' Stunning Transformation In "Orange Is The New Black" Season 2

The Whole Of “Orange Is The New Black” Season 2 Is Greater Than The Sum Of Its Parts

The Director And Star Of "Napoleon Dynamite" Look Back On The Cult Classic A Decade Later

World Cup Celebration In Rio Turns Into A Clash Between Police And Argentina Fans

New Law Puts Denmark At The Forefront Of Trans Rights In Europe

Everything You Need To Know About The Deadly Extremist Group Ravaging Iraq And Syria

Twitter Has Suspended An ISIS Account That Live-Tweeted Its Advance In Iraq

The 23 Worst Parts About Being Good At Grammar

If Dr. Seuss Books Were Actually About Kanye

13 Things J.K. Rowling Told "Nickelodeon Magazine" In 1999

17 Bookstores That Will Literally Change Your Life

Can You Make It Through This Video Without Feeling Your Skin Crawl?

When Science Fiction Becomes Science Fact

Should Two Children Be Imprisoned For Plotting To Kill Their Classmates?

Source Notes For "The Rise And Fall Of Chuck Blazer, The Man Who Built — And Bilked — American Soccer"

White House To Proceed With Federal Contractor LGBT Executive Order

Louisiana Authorities Say A Transgender Woman Was Held As A Slave, Tortured For Months

Why Andrew Rannells Replacing Neil Patrick Harris In "Hedwig" Is Fantastic News

This Wedding Proposal Stole The Show During Philly's Pride Parade

Reviewing Vintage Cosmo Dating Tips (with The Cast Of Undateable)

This Two-Minute Video Of A Cat Just Sitting In A Chair Is Perfect In Every Way

Crazy Custom Vehicles That Will Make You Rethink Your Ride

The Croatian World Cup Team Celebrated Losing To Brazil By Swimming Naked Together

19 Things The Saddest Man In The World Is Probably Thinking Right Now

Here Are The Most WTF Moments Of The World Cup's Opening Ceremony

New Spanx Denim Will Make Squeezing Your Organs Even More Casual

What Does Your Nail Polish Color Say About You?

21 Reasons Summer Sucks For Anyone With Big Boobs

A Cop At D.C. Pride Kissed His Boyfriend To Piss Off The Westboro Baptist Church

Shooting At Oregon High School, Two Confirmed Dead

An Oregon Couple Rushed Through Their Wedding Because Of A Wildfire And The Photos Are Breathtaking

24 Things You Didn't Know About Shake Shack

9 Ways To Set Up A DIY Drink Bar And Blow Your Friends' Minds

15 Times Ms. Frizzle From "The Magic School Bus" Should've Been Fired

USA Network Is Television's Best Answer To The Shifting Social Order

Why Black Women In America Are Being Told To Find Love In Europe

After A Girl Was Sent Home In Tears Because Her Dress Was Too Short, Her Mom Wore It To Graduation

This 3-Year-Old Was Reportedly Asked To Leave KFC Because Her Face "Scared Diners"

What American Products Are Called Around The World

Revisiting Movies That Awoke Your Sexuality

US Edition UK Edition Australia Brasil Español France

Just want to see NewsLifeEntertainment? Just News Just Life Just Entertainment

Fabulous! Don\'t forget to share with your friends on Twitter and Facebook.

remains one of television’s most buzzed-about series, the show is no longer the near-perfect adaptation that delighted viewers, both newcomers and established fans of George R .R. Martin’s

lost some of its luster, to the extent that what was once appointment viewing became the occasional slog. (Anyone up for an episode that takes place entirely at the Wall? Well, you’re getting one.) When it comes to production values and performances,

remains an impressive feat. But in looking back over Season 4, which concluded on June 15, it’s difficult not to reflect on where the show slipped and, at times, fell into disappointing mediocrity.

The scene in which Jaime rapes his sister-lover next to the corpse of their child will likely go down not only as Season 4’s biggest misstep, but also as the show’s most egregious mistake overall. It’s hard to imagine a bigger insult to the audience, to the characters, and to victims of sexual violence than the scene and the subsequent attempt by director Alex Graves to recontextualize a clear rape as rough consensual sex. “It becomes consensual by the end,” Graves said. It absolutely does not.

In fact, the rape scene in “Breaker of Chains” — allegedly intended to show an act of passion, not violence — was so mishandled that some have suggested pretending it never happened. And while that might seem like a radical step, it’s perhaps the only reasonable way we can really move forward. How else to take the scene in the season finale, in which Cersei confesses her undying love for Jaime to their father? What are we supposed to make of Jaime’s character development otherwise? In going for something edgy and shocking,

displayed a fundamental misunderstanding of rape and consent — not to mention the characters of Jaime and Cersei — and that grave error casts a serious shadow over the rest of the season, if not the series as a whole.

But Cersei’s rape wasn’t the only instance of sexual violence on

this season. To say that the show frequently depicts rape is not an automatic condemnation: Certainly there are ways it can work, when handled with the appropriate amount of respect and horror, in the context of the story. But in Season 4, rape became the worst kind of background noise, peppered throughout for no narrative reason other than to justify that TV-MA rating. Suddenly the notorious sexposition scenes of the first season felt almost quaint: Yes, the nudity, at times, was gratuitous. But at least that was consensual.

The worst example of Season 4’s casual relationship with rape — aside from the Jaime and Cersei scene, of course — was the scene at Craster’s Keep, in which the men of the Night’s Watch brutally raped Craster’s daughter-wives. That these rapes occured literally in the background of the scene reinforce the notion that sexual violence here has become a ghastly form of set dressing. Elsewhere, the threat of rape permeated nearly every episode. Whatever the intent may have been, these moments diminish the significance of sexual violence. By no means is

defending rape — but the series has become far too comfortable with haphazardly throwing it about, simply for the sake of cheaply raising the stakes or coloring a scene. This is a subject that requires serious thought and sensitivity, not carelessness and shrugs.

To some extent, this has been a problem with

from the beginning — and it speaks more to the unwieldiness of the source material. But in George R.R. Martin’s

A Song of Ice and Fire series, characters disappear for books at a time, returning only when they have something to do to propel the plot forward. On television, that might be harder to pull off: Imagine if a fan favorite like Daenerys was MIA for an entire season. For the first few seasons, however,

at least managed to condense the material and incorporate the characters in interesting ways. In Season 4, those tactics seemed to be falling apart.

As the show has gone on, we’ve been introduced to more and more new characters. (And yes, a whole slew of characters have also died. But we’re still gaining faster than we’re losing!) Perhaps more to the point, the characters have spread out in every direction, which means big group scenes are fewer and farther between. It’s difficult to say how

could solve this problem, but it made for an especially disparate season in which some characters were severely underserved. Frankly, the show might be better off going the route of

and purposely letting certain characters fall to the wayside for a season, rather than trying — and failing — to jump between them all.

did, for example, give Dany a break, we might be spared another season of Khaleesi dragging her feet on her inevitable return to Westeros. Again, this is a problem with the adaptation as a whole — the series’ writers must try to push their characters in a direction that falls in line with George R.R. Martin’s, though he has yet to finish his book series and tends to let his characters wander aimlessly for thousands of pages at a time. It’s a daunting task for the

writers, but without a clear solution, Season 4 felt more like an exercise in stalling than ever before.

It’s not as though there wasn’t plenty of action: The last two episodes in particular offered major battles and ample character death. The middle chunk of the season, however, often fell short. Yes, there were great moments — Oberyn offering to fight on Tyrion’s behalf, Littlefinger pushing Lysa to her death, all the scenes between Arya and the Hound — but taken as a whole, the episodes surrounding those moments dragged. And no, I’m not just referring to “The Watchers on the Wall,” set entirely at the Wall, though that was a particularly interminable slog. Too much of this season ended up being a waiting game: Tyrion waiting for the verdict, the Night’s Watch waiting for the wildlings, Dany waiting for an actual plot line. (Good luck with that one.) How did a season with such a staggering body count turn out so boring?

But then, even those deaths lost something. It’s no secret that George R.R. Martin loves killing his characters: It’s kind of his thing.

has followed suit, with some truly shocking and well executed character deaths, satisfying even for those viewers who already knew what was coming. Certainly some deaths had that effect in Season 4 — but others felt oddly perfunctory. There can be a strange matter-of-fact quality to the deaths in the books, but on TV, that doesn’t quite work. It ends up feeling anticlimactic. And when you shove so much death into one season, especially after the transcendent horror of Season 3’s Red Wedding, it starts to lose meaning.

Jojen’s death in the finale was a perfect example of this problem, made all the more interesting by the fact that Jojen hasn’t died in the books. The writers must have killed him off for a reason, but his death feels like a total waste of time. Why did Jojen have to die? And why should we care? Of course, viewer apathy toward Jojen’s demise also speaks to the issue of underserving characters: If

had done a better job fleshing out Jojen and Meera as characters, perhaps we’d feel more of a loss here. To suddenly take a moment for a tearful goodbye between siblings we never really got to know was too little, too late.

Of all the characters the show’s fourth season treated poorly, Shae may be the most tragic victim. Here’s an instance where the series initially improved on the books, turning Shae from a manipulative and untrustworthy prostitute into a well developed female character who shows genuine affection and compassion for Tyrion. But all that character development became meaningless when Shae very abruptly turned into a villain whom Tyrion was forced to strangle in self-defense. That’s not a fun twist — it’s lazy storytelling. You just can’t spend three seasons crafting a sympathetic character, only to have her do a sudden and absolute about-face because the plot calls for it.

Shae’s betrayal of Tyrion is equally abrupt in the book — but it was also a foregone conclusion. On the series, it’s baffling, and while Martin suggests there’s more to the story than what we’re getting, how much does that really matter now that she’s dead? It’s hard to maintain faith in a series with such careless characterization. Shifting allegiances are one thing, but Shae became an entirely different character in her final episode. It’s along the lines of — to beat this dead horse one last time — Jaime raping Cersei in one episode, and the couple behaving as though nothing happened in the next. The series is at its best when it depicts compelling characters in fantastical circumstances, as evidenced by the first three seasons. If

wants us to stick with an increasingly complicated story, it will need to return to its glory days of consistent characterization and strong plotting — no amount of sex and violence can make up for the absence of either.

58 Thoughts You Have While Playing The Simpsons: Tapped...

Rebuzzed! This post has been added to your Feed

I know, right? And there’s more where that came from.

Broken hearted? Maybe you’ll like something over here instead?

Oops! It looks like you\'ve already voted..

Thanks for Registering! Before you can vote or contribute we need to quickly validate your email address. We’ve sent you a confirmation email with instructions. If you don’t receive the email in a few minutes, please check your spam folder.

I know, right? Will your friends agree?

Where Season 4 Of "Game Of Thrones" Went Wrong

http://www.buzzfeed.com/louispeitzman/where-sea... The latest season of HBO’s hit fantasy drama looked perfect from far away, but up close it ...

8 Awesome Plot Twists From “A Storm Of Swords” That Weren’t In “Game Of Thrones” Season 3 ×

Watch 5 Mouth-Watering Moments From The "Game Of Thrones" Season 4 Trailer ×

The First 40 "Game Of Thrones" Episodes Ranked From Worst To Best ×

Where Season 2 Of “Revenge” Went So Very Wrong ×

26 Reasons Kids Are Pretty Much Just Tiny Drunk…

game of thrones, a song of ice and fire, game of thrones season 4, george rr martin, hbo, rape, rape on tv, sexual violence on tv, violence on tv, where game of thrones went wrong

Don\'t forget to share! Want to add another one? Go for it!

These Maps Show A Massive Gender Gap in Bicycle-Riding

Facebook Twitter Tumblr BuzzFeed Apps Newsletter

Kim Kardashian's Boobs Take North West For A Walk

Sorry, this post has been promoted by BuzzFeed editors so it can no longer be edited or deleted.

Sorry, this post cannot be edited at this time.

BuzzFeed is currently working with select partners to help them track what’s hot on their sites using the same advanced social tracking and analytics tools used on BuzzFeed.com.

Upload an Image Crop Image Are These Thumbnails Okay? ×

Preview Thumbnails Save Thumbnails Choose a new image Save

Oops! We had a problem sending your message. Please try again later.

Great! You\'ll get your first email soon.