ディズニープリンセス COUNTDOWN 6: Which 最近 DP film do あなた think most makes a parody of the ディズニー Princesses? Pick which one あなた find least offensive to the original franchise.

This question is now closed
32 fans picked:
Moana (2016)
   38%
魔法にかけられて (2007)
   34%
メリダとおそろしの森 (2012)
   25%
Maleficent (2014)
   3%
 asteriamalfoy posted ·10 か月前
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

11 comments

user photo
asteriamalfoy picked 魔法にかけられて (2007):
ROUND 1: Cinderella (2015) ELIMINATED
ROUND 2: The Princess and the Frog (2009) ELIMINATED
ROUND 3: Tangled (2010) ELIMINATED
ROUND 4: Beauty and the Beast (2017) ELIMINATED
ROUND 5: Frozen (2013) ELIMINATED

Still Enchanted.
posted ·10 か月前.
 
user photo
MalloMar picked Moana (2016):
Jokes a few times about tropes/clichés while using said tropes and clichés.
Beside that, this movie works.
posted ·10 か月前.
 
user photo
phalangeregina picked 魔法にかけられて (2007):
This is most classical in my country.
posted ·10 か月前.
 
user photo
sunnyfields picked Moana (2016):
Not too many negative comments in this movie. :D
posted ·10 か月前.
 
user photo
MaidofOrleans picked Moana (2016):
Hmm I guess Moana at this point. Again, I don't find any of these movies offensive except Enchanted. I'll just copy and paste what I wrote about Enchanted in my countdown: That whole thing about Giselle never having been angry before. Just ugh. Her personality is supposed to be based on the Classic DPs, as if they were never angry. Snow gets pretty annoyed with the dwarves when their standards of cleanliness don't meet her discerning eye, Cindy gets extremely pissed at Lucifer, her stepfamily, and even a clock, and Aurora is definitely livid with her aunts when they reveal she's a princess and has to go back to her parents. It's like the writers didn't even watch the source material.

Moana on the other hand isn't intended to be a parody. Yes, there's Moana's insistence that she isn't a princess, but that's Disney's attempt to be culturally accurate, not their denial of the Disney Princesses. Princesses are a primarily European concept, and the station comes with certain cultural connotations and expectations. Moana is not European, she's Polynesian. Being the daughter of the chief, although culturally the equivalent of a princess, does not make her a princess. Being the daughter of the chief in her culture comes with separate cultural connotation and separate expectations different from a European princess.
posted ·10 か月前.
 
user photo
Sparklefairy375 picked Moana (2016):
I don't see how Moana is a parody. Moana state that she isn't a princess, but daughter of chief instead. But it's sort of true as she's Polynesian and some of cultures include Polynesia didn't familiar with monarch system. Other than that Moana is typically a similar movie as earlier Disney princess movies such as Pocahontas and Mulan.
posted ·10 か月前.
 
user photo
lavendersblue picked Moana (2016):
Frozen went before this one?? It tries to be a deconstruction of fairy tales. Moana only has the "I'm not a princess" line, which I agree with MaidofOrleans on.
posted ·10 か月前.
last edited ·10 か月前
 
user photo
EmaSomolanyiova picked Moana (2016):
Agree with Sparklefairy.
posted ·10 か月前.
 
user photo
wavesurf picked Moana (2016):
Frozen is a FARCE. It went before this???
posted ·10 か月前.
 
user photo
KataraLover picked Moana (2016):
BY FAR
posted ·10 か月前.
 
user photo
Mongoose09 picked Moana (2016):
It has literally one line, lmao. agreed 100% with Sparklefairy & MaidofOrleans.

Frozen should be here over this.
posted ·10 か月前.