ディズニープリンセス Round 3: Which DP Film is the WEAKEST (Elimination によって Comments)

This question is now closed
33 fans picked:
眠れる森の美女
眠れる森の美女
   39%
The Princess and the Frog
The Princess and the Frog
   36%
塔の上のラプンツェル
塔の上のラプンツェル
   12%
白雪姫
白雪姫
   9%
シンデレラ
シンデレラ
   3%
リトル・マーメイド
リトル・マーメイド
no votes yet
美女と野獣
美女と野獣
no votes yet
アラジン
アラジン
no votes yet
ムーラン
ムーラン
no votes yet
 Jayden-G posted 1年以上前
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

11 comments

user photo
眠れる森の美女
Jayden-G picked 眠れる森の美女:
11. Brave
10. Pocahontas
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
Snow White and the Seven...
Beastlysoul25 picked 白雪姫:
Not a strong plot
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
塔の上のラ-- ンツェル
AudreyFreak picked 塔の上のラプンツェル:
There was a lot they put effort into when they made this movie, but a lot they forgot, ignored, or tried to brush off. There are SO many details visually speaking as well as in the Fridge Brilliance of it (look it up on Tvtropes if you haven't heard of that) but so many bad messages as a result of sloppy writing or just trying to manipulate the audience into ignoring or accepting them. They wrote so many loopholes for everything Rapunzel and Flynn do. That universe revolves around them and logic has no home there. A magical movie CAN be realistic in many ways (BATB, Cinderella) but this was so contrived. Strong points but many weak ones. I couldn't choose between this and PATF but I felt that PATF gets more flack than it deserves even though it's still very flawed.
posted 1年以上前.
last edited 1年以上前
 
user photo
The Princess and the Frog
rhythmicmagic picked The Princess and the Frog:
I'm sorry, I love this movie, but- the classics before this?
There plot is just too cluttered, too many loopholes, too many plot holes, and many things that simply aren't explained (or at least not obviously enough for most people.)
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
眠れる森の美女
princecatcher93 picked 眠れる森の美女:
TBH, it kind of had a boring plot and some many pointless filler scenes. They put to much work into it but it didn't do so well.
posted 1年以上前.
last edited 1年以上前
 
user photo
眠れる森の美女
Jayden-G picked 眠れる森の美女:
I have to choose this before PatF. Just because it is a classic does not mean that it should not get criticism for its flaws.

This movie does have some plot-holes and loopholes, but not even including that, it has a thin story with thin characters, many filler scenes and scenes that are too long/short. A lot is not explained, and there is a lot that could have used more development and explaining. This film lacks in every single aspect compared to the remaining films. I think this is one of Walt Disney's weaker works to be honest.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
The Princess and the Frog
JNTA1234 picked The Princess and the Frog:
I like it better than Tangled but this movie is so confusing and rushed.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
The Princess and the Frog
BelleAnastasia picked The Princess and the Frog:
Still voting for this movie for still the same reasons I gave in round 1.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
The Princess and the Frog
fiina picked The Princess and the Frog:
I think others are better.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
The Princess and the Frog
Swanpride picked The Princess and the Frog:
I'm actually stumped that so many people even consider Sleeping Beauty as weaker than The Princess and the Frog - or any other movie which is left, for that matter. Whatever their weaknesses are, they know exactly what they want to be and mostly stay on focus. TPatF on the other hand has many ideas, but not one of them are properly executed....the only thing which really works in Lottie.
posted 1年以上前.
 
user photo
塔の上のラ-- ンツェル
sisi_st picked 塔の上のラプンツェル:
Not very good IMO
posted 1年以上前.