この質問に回答する

ブレイキング・ドーン 質問

why didn't james laurant and victoria hear bella's heartbeat in the meadow? i thought that ヴァンパイア had really good hearing!!

 tdl posted 1年以上前
next question »

ブレイキング・ドーン 回答

ScottishChic said:
Yeah, I was confused about that too.

I think it's cause ヴァンパイア DO have heartbeats... Remember in Breaking Dawn when Jake went downstairs after he thought Bella was dead and he meant to kill Renesmee または something and it 発言しました "the sound of a changing heartbeat?"

so, maybe ヴァンパイア do have heartbeats...

but then again, Edward says. "my ハート, 心 hasn't beat in almost a hundred years" または something like that...

And to the Volturi they say, "You can hear her heartbeat"

Aw man! I just contradicted myself.

Maybe they were too preocupied with the Cullens?

And they really weren't expecting a HUMAN to be with ヴァンパイア so they certainly weren't expecting her.

I'll go with the preocupied excuse!
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
*
Thanks!! but that will always make me wonder. . . .
tdl posted 1年以上前
*
Renesmee's ハート, 心 beat because she's half human.
kuncuyug posted 1年以上前
Hellohoudini said:
Its one of the many flaws in the series....but guess what? I still 愛 it!

♥Team Twilight♥Forever♥
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
sweet-angle said:
very smart question

i think its a mistake

cause i know ヴァンパイア doesn't have heartbeat
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
MelissaSue21 said:
ヴァンパイア probably just tune it all out. Like Edward says he just ignores everyone's thoughts only listening to a few at a time. If ヴァンパイア paid attention to everyone's ハート, 心 beat または listened to everything it would be a constant clutter in their head. Remember when Edward took Bella hunting for the first time? He told her to listen and she really had to focus on everything to be able to hear the tiny things.
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
mizzsalvatore12 said:
well as Edward says (in the midnight sun draft )"vampires don't need to breathe but it did help when hunting" they mostly rely on sent and also they could have thought it was an animal but they do mostly rely on sent when hunting
select as best answer
posted 1年以上前 
next question »